News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

hn367621

Defective means a product doesn’t deliver on its specifications. For example if my LED desk lamp doesn’t promise to last any time at all, it’s not defective if it fails inside a month. If you want one that lasts longer, you pay more and can have that. Same for software. But most software basically promises nothing…
More like your engineering organization gets sued into oblivion because it created design processes with a single point of failure. Things happen all the time. That’s why well run organizations have processes in place to catch and deal with them.

In software, when people think it counts, they do too. The problem is not all people agree on “when it counts”

> physical engineering they don't have to

Totally agree with what you wrote but in any well run engineering organization one has to consider the cost/benefit of extra testing and engineering.

If you're making a USB powered LED desk lamp, you get into diminishing returns fairly quickly. If you're making basically anything on JWST, less so.

> You could ship faulty code to billions without anyone blinking an eye.

Not all software is equivalent and there is plenty of code that gets treated with the precision you're asking for.

But the ability to ship out code to billions in the blink of an eye is both the strength and the weakness of modern software.

It allows few engineers to tackle very complex problems without the huge investment in man hours that more rigor would require.

This keeps costs down enabling many projects that wouldn't see the light of day if the NRE was equivalent to HW.

On the other hand, you get a lot of "preliminary" code in the world, for lack of a better word.

At the end of the day all engineering is about balancing trade-offs and there are no right answers, only wrong ones. :)