News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

guido_vongraum

I'll stop as soon as dysgraphic flaggers stop. The true abuse is muting a comment that doesn't offend anyone, just calling to contemplate a philosophy so different from the current mainline it hurts. Or does it? Are they triggered by 'people should'? Yeah, they should, but don't have to. Is the very notion of impossibility to improve things forever without changing their essence offensive? Any other reason, could you explain it, please?
People should realize that ancient Chinese were оnto something when they told that all phenomena shall evolve only so much before they tip over the peak of maximum development and inevitably rumble downhill into overdevelopment.

P.S. the Holy Church of Progress keeps flagging the herecy of I-Ching out of existence, may it prevail in its glorious ways. Curious fact: expressing your disagreement in written form takes more neurons than flagging reflex does. Try and ye shall succeed!

Me being a caveman who believes that technology is a hammer that still can be used to drive nails into building materials instead of our own heads, I'm longing for an Intermesh of simple networked 8-bit machines running on vanilla (no ARM core bonuses) FPGAs, with CPUs simple enough to be predictable and understood not by a select few superhumans in the world, but by a critical mass of people, and communication protocols built from scratch with privacy and security in mind, so that such device could represent a social node: here's some info that I chose to make public, and there's my protected data. A single pedestrian FPGA could host a swarm of such tiny CPUs, each dedicated to a single task or security domain: a CPU to talk to shared filesystem, a CPU to talk to the private one, one more to process input, one to Tx/Rx bytes over the wire etc..

Or, if that is too complex, there could just be a bunch of breadboarded ICs capable of networking. There actually are real-world examples of such machines exposed via telnet, e.g. http://www.homebrewcpu.com

And all the performance beasts, while surely indispensable, could just enjoy their air-gapped solitude. Are there any massively parallel supercomputing tasks whose results couldn't be summarized and reduced to mere text, which is not too hard to move over the airgap manually?

I would have labeled the article a piece of defeatism disguised as satire, if not for this:

Security research is the continual process of discovering that your spaceship is a deathtrap. However, as John F. Kennedy once said, “SCREW IT WE’RE GOING TO THE MOON.” I cannot live my life in fear because someone named PhreakusMaximus at DefConHat 2014 showed that you can induce peanut allergies at a distance using an SMS message and a lock of your victim’s hair. If that’s how it is, I accept it and move on. Thinking about security is like thinking about where to ride your motorcycle: the safe places are no fun, and the fun places are not safe. I shall ride wherever my spirit takes me, and I shall find my Gigantic Martian Insect Party, and I will, uh, probably be rent asunder by huge cryptozoological mandibles, but I will die like Thomas Jefferson: free, defiant, and without a security label.

This I like.

Re:C++ UI Libraries on Saturday May 11, 2019 @05:28AM (#19885357)
Correct me if I'm wrong, but Windows ecosystem doesn't forbid e.g. Java applications to use the same system-wide JRE, which has to be installed once, manually. It would be a nightmare if every Java app installed its own copy of JRE. Still can happen, like in case of Processing, but that's more of an exception.
Re:C++ UI Libraries on Saturday May 11, 2019 @05:08AM (#19885313)
In the light of 290MB of scattered DLLs mentioned above, I believe that this is more than elegant way to advocate the guy who made this false claim - if you read carefully enough, you'll notice that it wasn't me. Care to check?
Re:C++ UI Libraries on Saturday May 11, 2019 @04:57AM (#19885291)
> if you want to take that chance

No, I don't think I want, now that you've sown a seed of doubt in my mind..

It's just occurred to me that he well might be a covert princess who'll jump out of my laptop, disguised as a frog, and demand me to kiss him in order to dispel the evil spell!

Re:C++ UI Libraries on Saturday May 11, 2019 @04:35AM (#19885227)
> he'll almost certainly fall victim to the Great Garbage Collection Algorithm In The Sky at some point, and now all of a sudden you're tied to a library that now literally nobody can legally maintain

Don't worry, you too are literally not going to be tied to such a library forever, you know :)

And I'm sorry to burst your bubble, but no software project, however open sourced and redundantly-maintained it is, is immortal either.

Re:C++ UI Libraries on Friday May 10, 2019 @04:17PM (#19881812)
Instead of paying $350 to a security analyst, I'd better pay them to an independent closed-source developer who makes a living from his software. Why would I trust some analyst more than the guy who works on his project with great care and dedication for over 10 years now?
Re:C++ UI Libraries on Friday May 10, 2019 @03:42PM (#19881535)
I believe 50MB is an exaggeration, but not too far-fetched one. More of a problem is the proliferation and duplication of these DLLs all over the storage when many Qt-based apps are installed. A quick Everything query shows that right now I've got 290MB of Qt*.dlls on my drive.
Re:C++ UI Libraries on Friday May 10, 2019 @03:16PM (#19881259)
> I don't know why Qt takes 50MBs or more for hello world or why anyone would use electron at all

You have all my sympathy here :) Well, it should also be noted that 5MB is the size of Sciter's dynamic library. Compiled statically, there will be less contributing to the app's size.

As to markup languages, well, maybe, but I think they are a lot more expressive for things that are styled, positioned via constraints, dynamic and animated. That's completely different approach compared to predefined component libs like WinForms etc.

Re:C++ UI Libraries on Friday May 10, 2019 @03:00PM (#19881089)
That separate language can be learned in a few days and leave you wondering how one guy managed to make things more logical than a crowd of people around JS.

If 5MB is a con, what do you say about 30MB for Qt and ~100MB for Electron?

Also, could you please elaborate on the first statement?

Re:C++ UI Libraries on Friday May 10, 2019 @02:45PM (#19880916)
Sciter is fantastic, and honestly I don't get it why being closed source is a con.

In fact, both 'commercial license / closed source' statements are not quite true - one may link against the precompiled dll for free, even in commercial apps (as cheap as that could be), while commercial licenses, starting from fair $310 (a lifetime license!), are there for those who need static linking, dedicated support and, mind you, access to the sources.

But even free users can expect a welcoming and timely response from the author (Sciter is a one-man affair). I, for one, never had a condescending or impolite reply to the dumbest of my questions.

Also, the article doesn't mention the fact that Sciter is more widespread than it might seem - for example, many Windows AV solutions, including Eset, Norton, Avast, Bitdefender and Comodo, use it as GUI engine.

What bothers me is the fact that everyone seems to be accepting the usage of these newspeakish romantically sounding euphemisms that are completely opaque about the purpose of things they stand for. "Normandy"... What is this - a place, a sort of champagne, a hotel or the internal name of some freaking area51 document?..

Like, "In order to disable Normandy, uncheck Vaduz, Monterrey, Vologda and select Newcastle in the Xinjang drop-down menu - we'll ship Bronx with next update".

P.S. Keep flagging, I'll repost, no problem.

>The UI knob is > Options -> Privacy & Security > Allow Firefox to install and run studies

Well it's a half-assed knob then, because it was unchecked and still I had app.normandy.enabled = true somehow.