News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

glorbol

Re:Hello, GitHub on Monday June 04, 2018 @05:52PM (#17232936)
While Microsoft has a lot of nice marketing and really good PR, they are still a corporation that makes money off selling SQL server licenses and office suite and increasingly by harvesting your user data.

Microsoft is addicted to your data. They siphon it off whenever they get the chance, often times by default and without your knowledge or consent. Even their cli Linux tools have """analytics""".

This will never change, no matter what slick marketing materials they produce, what PR fluff they have, or shills that shill for them.

The simple fact is I cannot trust Microsoft, especially to not touch code in my private repositories. I am sure they just want some "metrics" and to do some "analytics" on all the private data held in GitHub.

To use GitHub now, is to trust the same company who works hand in hand with the government and the NSA to make sure you stay insecure and known to agencies who just want to run some "metrics" and do some "analytics" on you.

No thanks.

I disagree, shelling out to another program is a perfectly reasonable design decision, one that has paid off in development speed. The people that run from their OS like it's something to be scared of are really missing out on the benefits of the their OS. I have built whole pipelines of essentially shell commands and I have never had a command injection vulnerability because I follow one simple rule:

I filter and sanitize input as soon as I receive it from the user. There are an infinitesimally small number of instances where you need to process anything but [a-zA-Z0-9]+ charset in a shell pipeline.

Once you have a pattern down for safely executing commands, there is no reason to be scared. It's really a myth that you can't become "secure", and this author's blog post is a perfect example. Tell me how you will conduct command injection when you have a whitelist of a-z0-9. I need an example, instead of this fear mongering that your OS is something to run and hide from.