gdpr_throwaway
I wanted to tell you how impressed I am with how patiently and clearly you've responded throughout this comment section.
I likewise think the intent of the law is admirable: prevent future Equifax-es, give people control over their data, and centralize the requirements so that companies need to comply with a single EU standard, instead of 28 country-specific ones. But the amount of discretion left to regulators and the lack of any sort of proportionality built into the law make this all very scary. We are expecting a fifteen person small business to have a totally impractical degree of _documentation_ and _formal_ processes, which are 1) very expensive to produce, 2) totally unnecessary for an otherwise reasonable and well-intentioned group of people, and 3) crucially, basically orthogonal to actual data privacy and security best practices.
And even if you comply with the letter of the law, just reading and understanding an email like the one in this post will require hundreds of dollars of company time – beyond reading it, it will need to be escalated, someone will need to loop in a few other people to help with any new technical details, and so forth. If the fully-loaded cost of a white collar employee is $75/hr, this all gets expensive very quickly, and that cost can be levied on a company by an email that can be sent in one minute. Nobody is going to bring down Google with GDPR-spam but it would not be hard to do serious damage to a company of ten people.
There are a lot of well-meaning thoughts in this thread from people who are frustrated at the status quo but unfortunately don't understand how little this law will do to change it and how huge its costs will be.
When you try to deliver a novel product and build a business around it, you are forced to develop a strong sense of practicality and an understanding of the machinery of a business. Most people have never done this. Despite being very intelligent, a lot of these people haven't experienced the realities of creating a business, and as a consequence they don't really understand just how harmful this kind of law can be.
I admire how patient and articulate you are. (And I think your thoughts are clear and your point of view is correct and badly needed.) Would love to buy you a beer sometime.