News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

floeng

You’re absolutely correct that in this area, his dynamic berm fits the hydrology, and that these are not good solutions in other places.

Examples:

- If the coast is too steep, the rocks won’t reach an equilibrium, and you now just have erosion of rock before your erosion of sand.

- If egg-laying sea/coastal life needs sand like sea turtles or some birds

- Surfers and tourism (as you mentioned)

- If the sand erosion is acting as a source for something downstream; stopping the sand movement will cause erosion in that area (nourishing the beach with sand would probably be a better fit)

(Edited formatting)

This… isn’t experimental. While the US Army Corps of Engineers might not have updated their shore protection manual to include “dynamic breakwaters [and beaches]”, we have design formulae to say what size rocks and what thickness of fill you need for your desired steady state* profile. Bonus points because the smaller rocks are significantly cheaper than the large, immobile armor units, and they can even withstand ice floes better if your coast freezes up.

* there will still be seasonal variation based on summer/winter wave patterns and weather.