floeng
Re:An Experimental Beach Barrier Could Be Key to Rebuilding Eroding Co...
on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:24PM (#35090365)
You’re absolutely correct that in this area, his dynamic berm fits the hydrology, and that these are not good solutions in other places.
Examples:
- If the coast is too steep, the rocks won’t reach an equilibrium, and you now just have erosion of rock before your erosion of sand.
- If egg-laying sea/coastal life needs sand like sea turtles or some birds
- Surfers and tourism (as you mentioned)
- If the sand erosion is acting as a source for something downstream; stopping the sand movement will cause erosion in that area (nourishing the beach with sand would probably be a better fit)
(Edited formatting)
Re:An Experimental Beach Barrier Could Be Key to Rebuilding Eroding Co...
on Thursday March 09, 2023 @11:05PM (#35090228)
This… isn’t experimental. While the US Army Corps of Engineers might not have updated their shore protection manual to include “dynamic breakwaters [and beaches]”, we have design formulae to say what size rocks and what thickness of fill you need for your desired steady state* profile. Bonus points because the smaller rocks are significantly cheaper than the large, immobile armor units, and they can even withstand ice floes better if your coast freezes up.
* there will still be seasonal variation based on summer/winter wave patterns and weather.