News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

epdotnet

I tested the demand for this and my experience is that there aren't enough buyers willing to pay for the kind of expertise required to curate listings based on some basic due diligence checks, filtering out obvious fakery, and using standard business valuation models to suggest a price range for sites being auctioned in Flippa. You've got to bear in mind that it's very time intensive work to get to the real figures. For example, most sellers don't deduct a nominal cost for their own time. To "normalize" their accounts you'll have to first decide how much of time/expertise is required to run their business and what that would cost.
Thanks to sheff for mentioning my non-profit experienced-people.net forum which discusses website purchases and sales. This site has sent us a fair bit of traffic yesterday :-)

Flippa is one of the many avenues one can use to sell a site or find one to buy. It has a high profile but in dollar terms accounts for a small proportion of online businesses sold. However, it's a popular location for webmasters and lower end websites and I recommend the flipfilter.com site for stats on the Flippa marketplace.

My own analysis is somewhat different. As I commented in the sparklewise blog (the OP link), figures you see in Flippa are deceptive. The $200K site mentioned at (D) in his blog post was sold a month later by the same seller for $40K. The chances are the first sale didn't go through. That's not an isolated case. I would advise that readers exercise caution, it's easy to get carried away with the large figures :)

I've been doing my own analysis of some Flippa stats (http://experienced-people.net/forums/showthread.php/6331) and the numbers are just not adding up for me.

Tom, as a long term watcher of website marketplaces, and the owner of the experienced-people forum, I completely agree with your assessment. Flippa did go down the route of quantity (more profit in listing fees) rather than quality. We did advise them when they started up that this would affect trust.
Thanks for mentioning my forums. We do have a Due Diligence section on the forums in addition to ones on valuation, buying of websites, selling websites etc.

In my ten years plus of buying websites, I've noticed one massive change - the decline in quality and truth. Sellers have become very sharp at scamming buyers - faking traffic, faking revenue, faking the prospects of the business. It's a mine field and it's largely due to the emergence of the career seller, someone who creates sites just to sell. He is unable to make money with the site himself, but has an incentive to convince others that they can make money out of it.

Some of them run "site flipping" courses and talk a lot about "passive income from websites". Flippa has encouraged these site flippers as all their chatter does drive business.

Our forum has long been cynical and critical of some of these practices and we are, I believe, the largest destination on the internet for intelligent, unbiased comment on the subject of buying and selling websites and have exposed some of the biggest site selling scams on the internet including those of a couple of really sharp, high-end "template" sellers swindling buyers out of $50K+ for sites worth less than $500!

The "Just Sold" section, sheff, is filled with a fair amount of fiction. Many of those sites that have apparently sold ... haven't! I posted an example of this in a comment at your blog.