News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

edmundedgar

Re:Mainnet Merge Announcement on Thursday August 25, 2022 @03:16AM (#32590611)
That's not related to the complexity of the thing. Imagine Token Ring had a token, and there were a bunch of people invested in the idea that it was better than all the alternatives.
Right - I guess the open question at this point is how much weight those mechanisms can bear. Bitcoin has a very easy version of the problem, because all they need to do is time-stamping, where you just have to follow the rules and run your software without hacking it to stay in line with the consensus.

As described the problem TruthCoin is trying to solve puts a lot more stress on the consensus mechanism, because it requires the participants to do more work to stay in line with the consensus.

In practice I think what ends up happening is that somebody publishes a feed and everybody pulls their results from that and "votes" as they're told to by the feed. This may not be too bad in itself as the feed is probably not too bad, and the people publishing it probably have an incentive to keep publishing good data. But I do worry that this system will make it hard to get off the de-facto default data feed if it starts producing bad data, since it's designed to punish people who step outside the consensus...

The other problem when you try to censor this is that the illegality and immorality of these contracts actually depends on the intention, which you can't see on a public network. TruthCoin (or any other anonymous system for doing this) wouldn't be able to tell the difference between a payment to somebody to burn down the lighthouse and an insurance contract to help you rebuild the lighthouse if it burns down.

Likewise, for all you'll know looking at the transactions, a payment conditional on someone's death could be a will, a life insurance policy, a political bet or an assassination contract. These all look the same to the network; What matters is the intention behind them.

I think the ability to make these contracts is inevitable, with or without TruthCoin, and it's futile trying to censor them.

You can get these contracts settled by any trusted party, or any combination you choose of trusted parties. There's already someone out there who is offering to escrow money if you want to assassinate a politician. The next logical step is for them to use multi-sig and act as an arbitor, but without the need to hold the funds. It's inevitable that someone will do this, if they're not doing it already.

If anything it would be better to have this activity happening on a public network so that law enforcement can find out who somebody is trying to assassinate etc.