economist6373
Good enforcement is impossible without subjecting anybody trading stocks and everybody they know to a completely unprecedented level of surveillance. This would have to go far beyond the wildest Snowden revelations.
Perhaps not completely impossible in theory, but absolutely infeasible in practice. Building such a system would also be likely to result in far greater chilling effects on the markets than insider trading ever could.
Such activities would be criminal regardless of insider trading. What difference could it possibly make if insider trading was legal?
Should we maybe add more laws to forbid such activity in different creative ways, so instead of being doubly illegal it would be triply illegal?
Crazy.
The argument that insider trading should be banned because it is somehow disproportionately unfair is quite weak, the argument that it creates an impression of unfairness is a much stronger one.
I personally don’t believe it is a particularly good argument, but it is certainly the strongest version of the argument against insider trading.
> I think it would be dishonest to do so actively
That is what the government is doing via legislation.
What you are describing is an entirely different kind of misconduct than “insider trading”.