drinkislande
drinkislande on Hacker News
Honestly, I don't understand why there's so much cynicism regarding Quantopian and their contest.
I think it's great that there's a tool people can use to get started with automated system trading.
For all of you who are whining about stuff, do realize that no one is being forced to enter the contest. Did you get that? NOT REQUIRED.
On the other hand, for those of us who want to learn or try our hand, this is a great idea/product.
It really depends how you're using the random coin tossing. Are you going through a list of securities then tossing a coin and if it's heads you'll buy it, if it's tails, you'll sell? How will you allocate your capital? If it's heads you'll put commit 10% or your balance and if it's tails, 20%?
Will you use coin tosses for your exit parameters as well?
While coin tossing in and of itself is random, the manner in which you use it is not. So at the end of the day, your 'completely random strategy' may not actually be all that random...
Just something to think about.
Process means nothing if it doesn't have good returns. You can have the best analysts and if something goes wrong, you still have good "process" but you'll have peanuts to show for it.
At the end of the day, what matters? Your returns - that's why people invest.
I take it neither of you have ever read "What Works on Wall Street"? crack it open, and tell me it's impossible to beat the market.
Just because lazy people advocate buying index funds doesn't mean it's automatically the best choice.
If you're just satisfied with mediocrity, then fine, do it. However one trait of successful humans is that they seek to improve upon the status quo.
It's such a shame that we have people posting comments online when they haven't the slightest clue what they're talking about. Do you really believe finance is a valueless and damaging industry?
If so, do you realize that all the electronics you're using to post your nonsensical comment were made possible BECAUSE of finance?
Sure not everything in finance is good - but that's the same in any other industry. In tech you have people who write programs to destroy other people's data, in biology, you have people trying to create bio-weapons. EVERYTHING has the potential to be damaging!
But finance, finance makes it possible to have all the amazing advances we've had! How could small companies be able to grow and spend on R&D as they did without the aid of financing?
Just because it's hip to bash finance, doesn't mean it's right. Don't be a brainless sheep mindlessly following others. Try thinking for yourself, you might be surprised with what you come up with.