News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

daviswithanS

"Dear passengers, people who travel without a ticket, or behave disorderly, or smoke in public areas, will be punished according to regulations and the behaviour will be recorded in individual credit information system. To avoid a negative record of personal credit please follow the relevant regulations and help with the orders on the train and at the station."

To me, this is the most worrisome part of the article. The implementation of an "individual credit system" would grant an administration an unprecedented amount of control over the lives of individuals, from policing the actions of an individual within their own home, punishing those who deviate from their "proper" social roles (imagine an individual losing credit for being openly gay), or actively suppressing any perceived threat to the administration. Taxing sugar or requiring companies to put warning labels on their products is laughably tame compared to this level of invasiveness.

"And although the American tech giants have become accomplished data vampires in their own right, they are mere amateurs compared to their Chinese counterparts, who are not hampered by concerns about data protection, privacy or even the rule of law."

I was under the impression that "deep blue" states were more effective than red states at implementing privacy laws. Think of California's Consumer Privacy Act. At any rate, the article says that "any data a local company holds effectively belongs also to the state". I don't know of a comparable policy in any state here in the US.

I recently had the pleasure of reading the book Outliers, also by Malcolm Gladwell. In this book, one of his techniques is to present the typical "genius" or "rags-to-riches" type story and pick it apart, showing that success comes more frequently from environment and having the opportunity to work hard than from some innate genius. Here he uses the same technique. He presents the popular conception of Ben Fountain's story - a man quits his job and becomes a successful author through talent and motivation. Then, throughout the rest of the article, he adds nuance and exposes some of the overlooked details - that man was supported financially by his wife, had free time throughout the day to work, developed his talent excruciatingly slowly and took almost twenty years to catch his first break. While the focus of this article was more to discuss what it means to be or become a genius, I find it refreshing to think that these kinds of success stories often have hidden details that allow them to feel more realistic and attainable.

On a more personal level, I really appreciated this article. I recently made the decision to study music at a conservatory rather than go into programming as I had originally planned. Programming has always been something I've been naturally good at (I used to think of myself as a very technical, STEMmy kind of person - I laugh at that now), whereas performing music is a passion I've only recently rekindled. As a result, I've had a few doubts about my ability to become a good musician or whether I've made the right choice. This article, however, reassures me that being born with innate talent is not the only path to becoming a good musician (although it sure would have been nice).