News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

bji

Re:Krugman on BitCoin on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:21PM (#2976096)
You would have been stupid to spend the bitcoins last year only if the value of having a motorcycle for a year was less than the accrued value of the bitcoins as they appreciated in value over that time. Because people cannot predict the value of bitcoins over time perfectly, and because the satisfaction of immediate needs/wants is often more important than a greater later return, bitcoins would always be spent even in a deflationary system.
Re:Krugman on BitCoin on Thursday September 08, 2011 @07:13PM (#2976075)
Bitcoins are not simply prime numbers. They are account balances in a system that distributes the validation of account balances in such a way that is cryptographically secure, trustable, and decentralized. Provably correct, tamper-proof accounting balance sheets are nothing to sneeze at and it was really a stroke of genius to discover the algorithmic means to create such a thing that is the cool thing about Bitcoin.

I personally believe that it will never achieve anything other than niche status as a currency for trading illegal goods; it will be used for other types of transactions, but it will be a very small number of transactions when compared to contemporary financial transaction systems like, e.g. credit cards, or paypal. I say this only because in practical terms it is not very easy to use, and furthermore, its benefit of being pseudoanonymous is also is downfall; very safe for the recipient to receive bitcoins but very risky for the sender to send them since the sender has absolutely no insurance or any recourse in the transaction. There is no authority to appeal to for transactions gone bad, and even if you could sue over bitcoin transactions and the courts would understand them, the pseudoanonymity would make it very difficult to know who to sue.

Re:Krugman on BitCoin on Thursday September 08, 2011 @04:38PM (#2975567)
Do any desirable economic conditions come out of a deflationary system? What I mean is, is there any economic outcome desired by any world view that is best served by continuous monetary deflation?

If someone wanted the social trend to be towards historic lifestyles, would deflation accomplish that? It's hard to phrase what I am trying to ask so I hope I am being clear. Imagine that someone wanted everyone to live like the Amish. Would persistent deflation accomplish that? Would persistent deflation produce a world where people spend less of their time feverishly trying to make more money and more of their time enjoying what they already have? Would persistent deflation reduce the rate at which we destroy the environment around us?

If inflationary economic systems reward those with money to leverage into investment returns, do deflationary systems reward those who do not? If inflationary systems encourage people to lend out the product of their labor to others to use to create their own wealth, do deflationary systems discourage this, and if so, would the result be that it would be harder for people who are at an economic disadvantage to better their situation? Conversely, would it be harder for people who are at an economically advantageous position to increase their wealth because investment vehicles are less numerous and more risky?

I get the feeling that some people believe that economic growth is an objectively desirable outcome; but must it always be? I do not know exactly how I feel about it, but I feel that it doesn't seem like it should be the given that others seem to believe that it is.