News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

bigwig8702

Re:Being Slow to Criticise on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @03:13PM (#30263944)
Oh look, a big angry reaction to a simple assertion that you should try to look at code and criticisms about code objectively.
Re:Being Slow to Criticise on Tuesday February 08, 2022 @12:33PM (#30261491)
I think there's two important aspects of this article:

1) Assume the people who wrote the code aren't stupid.

2) Be nice to developers

Point #1 is valid, because yes a lot of times intention is difficult to suss out and the guy who wrote it might have known something you didn't, or maybe the circumstances were different when it was written.

Point #2 is just wrong, it goes against the entire principle of Egoless Programming. Like you said about Ribbon, if it sucks you need to just admit it and either make it better or scrap it. It's just software, people don't need to incorporate every bug they write into their personal feelings of self-worth. If anything developers should embrace criticism, there might be lessons there to learn.