bawr_hszm
Basically, since the reference count is kept right before the object data, as soon as the child process touches it - even just to look at it! - you immediately trigger a copy on write on the nearest 4k of memory, which tends to add up fast if you're not careful. Even if you never touch 99% of them, the garbage collector is happy to do it for you.
At my previous job it was bad enough that I ended up writing a small patch to be able to set some refcounts to 0xFF...FF and treat them specially, never changing their value. (Yes, this also meant that they never got destroyed properly, and the extra checks made our codebase around 4% slower, but it was an acceptable tradeoff. No, the patch was no longer small by the time it hit production.)
Thanks for being good with my grumpy feedback!
In this example, the program spends a third of the time just sleeping / blocked, a third of the time on CPU but at the C level, and the remainder just evaluating Python loops. Unless you already know how it's implemented, that 33.66% is not easy to interpret, and the docs don't mention what exactly is being profiled. Specifically, these samples aren't a % of CPU time, they're a % of real time that we happened to have been able to do a Python-level interrupt, and even that isn't a great explanation. I think most users would still expect line 22 to get traced properly.
I very much do want to know about C time, too, because it's very much actionable for most of the optimizations I end up making in production systems.
That said, I don't think this line of discussion is super productive for either of us, we seem to have different goals in mind, which is fine. ;)
So I'll close by saying that I was impressed by your LD_PRELOAD hacks for memory profiling, which isn't an approach that I've ever seen in other Python profilers.
To wit:
$ python -m scalene trace.py
f1 1.3852 312499987500000
f2 1.2420 2812499962500000
f3 1.5018 1.5
trace.py: % of CPU time = 33.66% out of 4.13s.
Line | CPU % | [trace.py]
1 | | #!/usr/bin/env python
2 | |
3 | | import time
4 | |
5 | | def timed(f):
6 | | def f_timed(*args, **kwargs):
7 | | t = time.time()
8 | | r = f(*args, **kwargs)
9 | | t = time.time() - t
10 | | print('%s %.4f %s' % (f.__name__, t, r))
11 | | return f_timed
12 | |
13 | | @timed
14 | | def f1(n):
15 | | s = 0
16 | 17.99% | for i in range(n):
17 | 81.29% | s += i
18 | | return s
19 | |
20 | | @timed
21 | | def f2(n):
22 | 0.72% | return sum(range(n))
23 | |
24 | | @timed
25 | | def f3(t):
26 | | time.sleep(t)
27 | | return t
28 | |
29 | | if __name__ == '__main__':
30 | | f1(25_000_000)
31 | | f2(75_000_000)
32 | | f3(1.5)