News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

b0ttler0cket

Exactly, the beauty of the law is that almost always, the outcome is decided on a case to case basis.

It used to be less case-to-case when there were mandatory minimums. These were basically algorithmic processes to output a time range for imprisonment during sentencing. Judges had to abide by these sentencing tables. Since then, they have been abolished and judges are now empowered to make the decision themselves based on the facts of the case.

There are situations in which the outcome is not decided case-to-case. These situations are called "strict-liability" where if you commit a violation, you are punished no matter what. Thankfully, these aren't crimes. Usually, it's if you double park, you're getting a ticket. It doesn't matter whether you had the intent.

A tagger who has the nerve to tag a police station is more likely to be involved in violence than a fairly educated 17 year old adolescent who codes. Why is this not reasonably fair to say? I don't understand.

We're talking about tagging a police station. That's a direct affront to the authority that (arguably) establishes a respectable degree of order and attempts to ensure peace (lack of violence). A person who expresses contempt or animosity towards those who (in general) attempt to ensure peace seems to be a person that would perpetrate violence...right?

Why is this wrong? (I'll just throw in a little something to tell you I have an idea of what I'm talking about). I grew up in the projects where undercover police would ride around in taxi cabs and basically sit like homeless people near subway entrances. This is a very tense environment, and I've seen many people arrested with a fair amount of force by the police. I also saw the remains of numerous gunfights a few times while coming home from school. Now imagine tagging a police station in this kind of environment. It's quite a task isn't it? Certainly a person who spends their time coding could be considered less violent prone, right?

Good points, roel. I want to say something about my "logic." I compared two similar scenarios. You're comparing industrial sabotage to tagging a wall. It's not fair to say that because this comparison fails, my logic is wrong is it? You set it up purposefully to fail. It's kind of straw-man-ish.

Is stealing a wallet with $10.00 worse than wiring $10.00 from someone else's account? I could easily argue yes in some circumstances. If you have your wallet stolen by someone, there's a much greater chance that you will come to physical harm. Getting $10.00 stolen from your PayPal account does not afford you this same risk. I believe that's pretty fair to say. Now, seeing as one has the potential to cause financial and physical harm and the other only has the potential to cause financial distress, should both crimes be treated the same? Should both perpetrators be punished with the same sentence if convicted?

That being said, industrial espionage is a serious thing, and at that point the distinction between a "cyber-crime" and a "real-world crime" begins to diminish.

My logic still holds up, doesn't it? Am I still missing something here?

"So long both teenagers are first time offenders, then the justice system should treat them the same."

Once again, I can't agree. That is not the only consideration taken into account. Absolutely not. That doesn't even begin to skim the surface of what's taken into consideration in sentencing and during the trial.

Here's a classic counter-example to this assertion.

PersonA steals prescription medicine to sell so he can buy more drugs to deal. PersonB steals prescription medicine so he can sell them and pay for his wife's dialysis.

That's the same crime, and let's say they're both first time offenders. Would they be treated the same? No. It's called mitigating factors. PersonB has more mitigating factors than PersonA, and is therefore not treated the same.

Yeah. That. But let's make sure we understand the point of his example. The whole point of the law is to take trials on a case by case basis. More often than not there is no broadly sweeping rule that will dictate the outcome of the case. The phrase "a rule sweeps too broadly," is common in legal parlance. (I studied law for 4 years. I have some experience with this). The kids who cause more damage will get a heavier punishment. That is simply just. What is unjust is robbing them of a huge chunk of their lives. Justice is about contextualization. We have to ask questions like; is it reasonable that they should have known better? Did they intend to bring down a power plant? Did they mean to cause bodily harm?

But 10 years for a 17 year old. Can't seem to wrap my head around that.

Think about what you're writing. There's a huge difference. One is writing a few pieces of code. The other exists in the physical world. That means the person spray painting the police station ("house") effects a greater magnitude of real-world consequences. For example, a person who is willing to tag a police station is more likely to be involved in violent behavior involving lethal weapons than the prankster who changes a few lines of code. The one and the other are NOT the same. Saying they are is a really dangerous idea...think about why. How could you possibly treat the street hood and the 17 year old prankster in the same way...

What theory of justice would that fall under?

Wow...to think that he would be 27 before he ever got out. I wonder how it's possible for the government to penalize a 17 year old with 10 years of prison. That's the equivalent of a class c felony in the US, which can be applied to sexual assault, arson, and kidnapping.

To think that a computer crime where not even any "sensitive personal or financial information was stolen" can be considered at par with kidnapping is harsh.

Re:Ask HN: How to develop competitive spirit? on Friday April 05, 2013 @01:27AM (#5496925)
Oops. Sorry. :)
Re:Ask HN: How to develop competitive spirit? on Friday April 05, 2013 @12:41AM (#5496820)
I have to disagree.

I don't like to think of this as a necessary evil. Given the OP's philosophy, I definitely don't think it's appropriate to describe what he should do as an "evil."

It can be done differently. He's not questioning the fact that there's "only a limited number of businesses [that] can exist in any one market." Jh understands that the world is finite. What he doesn't understand is that this concept of "hurting" someone is not real. It's not sports, where the aim is to defeat the opponent (yes that is the aim of sports...I know what I'm talking about there). This is business. If there's too much in one place, go somewhere else. Jh's problem is that he can't go anywhere else. He's stuck in the middle of nowhere because every decision is blocked by an internal rule he has written.

There is no necessary "evil" here, there's just necessary. You have to abandon your train of thought. :) That is, if you want the solution to your dilemma. :)

Re:Ask HN: I'd like your opinion on my social network idea on Friday April 05, 2013 @12:30AM (#5496790)
I have a feeling that if you have all of these other features (statuses, profiles, messages...), why not just stick in notes, groups and pages? I feel like (what you're saying) the big problem is that FB became a huge clutter of some sort. I gather this from the way you say "whatever the hell Facebook is becoming." However, it seems like in trying to cut down the tree, you end up just snipping a few branches off by cutting out notes, groups and pages. :)

That's just a minor observation. I think t0 says something really cool. It's about doing one thing really really good. Maybe it's reinventing the statuses system. Or maybe it's about the calendar.

By the way, you do realize that you say one of your features is to "manage a calendar which your friends can "pin" events, notes, and photos to," but then you say right after that, "no notes" will be included as features. :)

I would say give this a little more thought. :)

Re:Ask HN: How to develop competitive spirit? on Friday April 05, 2013 @12:17AM (#5496750)
As a side note (because your way of thinking is very interesting), here's a small thought exercise. I would love to know what you would do in this situation. (This might further convince you that the way you think fails some tests). I think taking the time to really understand this train of thinking is important, as it will dictate many of your decisions in the future. :)

ActionA hurts 1 person. B,2 C,3 D,4

Which one do you chose? A or no choice? To compound the problem.

ActionA hurts 1 person you really like. B,2 ppl you kinda like; C,3 ppl you are ambivalent towards; D,4 ppl you utterly dislike (each emotion containing logical reasons, e.g. A is your girlfriend, D is a cruel warlord.)

Now your decision might change, might it not? This is how I demonstrate to you why uncertainty destroys any chance you have of effectively making decisions.

So in all, I believe your way of thinking fails at 3 levels.

1. You believe your actions always hurt someone, though not realizing that because you're a capable and well-meaning person, your inaction may hurt many many more people.

2. You believe firmly (so firmly that you don't commit to anything you want to do in life) that you are dealing with information when you are in fact dealing only in pure, non-founded speculation. You have NO basis to believe you are hurting people. You speculate. I would say you have information that you are hurting people when you can tell me the names of who you're hurting. This is a bad illusion to live under. It gives you the feeling that your making an active decision to do something when all you're doing is absolutely nothing except believing you've made an active decision. You set yourself a devious little trap.

3. You do not have enough information to use the system you are using. Even if you had enough information (as demonstrated above) you would need additional rules and ways to rank the impact of your actions and who they impact, which you currently completely lack.

I know this is going to help you. Let it. If I was in your situation and someone told me this, it would've helped me. :)

Re:Ask HN: How to develop competitive spirit? on Friday April 05, 2013 @12:02AM (#5496716)
Dear jhjhjhjhj,

1. Not acting is hurting someone too.

You can look at this from a psychological standpoint. I've read the other comments and I agree with some of them, especially mnicole's in which s/he says "you're opening the door for another or making them step up their game." You may be "hurting" someone, but you have the potential to help many more. So from a philosophical point, you are solid. Just remember that breaking a window to employ the window maker does not add to the system. It actually just leaves you minus a window. If you don't commit to your ideas, you're breaking the window.

2. You don't have enough information. Uncertainty.

You can look at this also from a logical standpoint. What you're saying is you are immobilized due to various reasons. These reasons, we call constraints. You are in a situation saturated with so many constraints that you can effectively do nothing. Start one thing, find bad implications, stop. Start another, stop. This is a signature sign of a bad and failing system. You HAVE to change the rules by default, assuming you want to develop a better system.

As such, forget this rule:

If I "affect someone else badly directly or indirectly, I stop working on it."

This to me is the equivalent of voodoo magic. You cannot quantify or in anyway measure the extent of your negative impacts. This means you are in a system rife with uncertainty. The special quality of uncertainty (as the 2002-2008 WS financial engineers observed) is that no matter what metrics you use, it is unquantifiable and that an overabundance denotes a system bound to fail. Your system of decision is therefore one that fails. It is not grounded in reality, but in uncertainty. You sound like a smart person ("proficient developer and entrepreneur"). You must be able to see why this is true.

Do not make decisions based on uncertainty. There's literally nothing you can do for these people you believe you might be hurting. Make decisions on reality. Go for what you want. Develop your projects and feel liberated doing so.

Now, having reconciled our philosophy with our logic, I hope you can find a better peace of mind to continue onward. :)

Weil es ein bisschen lustiger ist. :)
Re:Seriously: what's the "next big thing" in tech? on Thursday April 04, 2013 @11:28PM (#5496632)
(b0ttler0cket):

What's the next big thing? It may not be all that hard to perceive. You're on Hacker News so you may be biased immediately to think it has something directly to do with programming and computers. Take a step back from that first, and you can immediately think of a couple.

1. Privacy/advertisements. (how are people going to sell things to us?)

2. Press/print materials. (print? it's gonna be old news right? save the trees?)

3. Security (everything's in the open now. how do we adjust? how do we protect information?)

4. Health (we shouldn't have as many problems as we do)

5. Transportation (our cities are getting bigger and "rural" is a word that basically means "hard to transport to.")

6. Environment (our environment is imminently approaching toxic and uninhabitable levels of pollution)

7. Energy (our resources are rapidly and imminently depleting)

8. Economics (crypto-what?)

9. Architecture (these buildings need to get way higher and more sophisticated. we're going to hit 9B ppl soon. rural chinese farmers are swarming to the cities (read that in an article). it's the worldwide trend. the buildings of the future:the buildings of today::the buildings of today:17th century colonial houses)

10. Engineering (okay, so a transatlantic underwater tunnel would be the single highest costing thing humankind would have ever attempted. even still, what more can we do? is the San-Francisco bridge et al. the best we got?)

11. Education (this is covered by every politician and so should be self-explanatory. more wide-spread systems of education. online is a start, but I read in an article (I think posted on HN) that the drop out rate is too high.)

12. Food (more people, more crops. more crops, more transportation, more oil, more livestock, more energy expended. Not to mention, bio-engineered food that produces more vitamins/essential nutrients - depending on who you ask, this is either a blessing or a curse)

I feel like categorization is helpful here. You ask for the next big thing, but that question is so enormous. One person could say one thing, but how could another person argue against it being the next biggest? Is there a metric with which we can compare impact? And impact on what? Society? Businesses? Individual people? Microorganisms? I think if you categorize like this you'll have a much easier time thinking and ranking ideas. Comparing the next ideas in architecture and the next ideas in food development is quintessential apples and oranges. Here we're making it so that we can make better subjective judgments about what's a more important idea.

Re:Ask HN: Music startup vs. Audio startup? on Thursday April 04, 2013 @12:22PM (#5493482)
(b0ttler0cket):

This may be an interesting idea. I do not know too much about the music industry, except from what I've read and the people I've talked to. Here's a quote I remember reading from PG (taken directly).

"...record labels...are effectively a rogue state with nuclear weapons. There is nothing we or anyone else can do to protect you from them, except warn you not to start startups that touch label music."

I am not sure if that is ample enough advice, but it is a strong warning. I don't exactly know what "touching" label music means, but I'm assuming it would apply to your situation since I have a feeling that the vast majority of the "audio" would be music. Self-produced music is fine (as long as it doesn't have 7 or more consecutive notes that belongs to another song, I believe), but I think you may have problems when people start to post label music on your site. From what I understand (I've studied law for 4 years), labels can begin to file copyright claims against you. It's common practice and unless you have the legal firepower to combat it, you and your company may be quickly smothered by legal issues and fees (and even damages).

In all, I think the risks here far outweigh the rewards. Even from the perspective of managing schlep for gains, I think this battle is so uphill it's like trying to scale a vertical wall. I have a strong feeling that you'll have much more fun with another project. :)

Re:Ask HN: Resources for Studying Multivariable Calculus? on Thursday April 04, 2013 @12:05PM (#5493401)
As I said before, I'd continue to look. Here is another outline provided by East Tennessee State University that I think is fairly worthwhile.

(http://math.etsu.edu/multicalc/prealpha/)

NB: I'll be using the first link to study Calc3 after I finish doing the AP Calc problems in my book first to review. :)

Re:Ask HN: Are you still employable after being a founder? on Thursday April 04, 2013 @10:56AM (#5493009)
(b0ttler0cket):

I think this question has a lot to do with risk and reward. Graham addresses this (at this point, it's a bit of a blur. Whenever I hear something like this, I just randomly pull out some of this reasoning).

I may not be able to paraphrase exactly, but in regards to your question about regret and risk, the reasoning may have gone something like this:

1. Age is important. Younger people can afford to take more risks for the simple reason that they seem to have more time to mitigate any damage from the mistakes should they fail. Also, younger people are less likely to be parents already or have a family.

2. Attitude is important too. Some of this comes down to what you can better tolerate. Startups are like sprints. Employment is like long distance running. Do you want to cram the bulk of your expendable energy into a few years of intensely hard work (and stress) with an uncertain payoff, or do you want to work moderately with a very decent payoff and still have the time to enjoy family, a relationship, long walks in the park, jogging after work for as long as you want, weekend-long trips to the beach. I feel like a lot of people in HN, if given the choice between startup and employment, would say startup hands-down. But if you look at it this way, I believe the decision is a little harder for many people.

3. Maybe the most important. You have to believe in yourself, your product, and your ability to come up with ideas if you want to do this. I cannot picture a scarier situation (in regards to startups) than starting one full of doubt, anxiety, and overall insecurity. If you do this, you have put all your chips in the pot, keeping in mind that there's no bluffing and no turning back (well there might be turning back, but you definitely shouldn't be planning to). You have to have the cards to back up your all-in. Having the cards means having the guts to stick it through, having some level of smart, being adept at troubleshooting problems, and having a fairly good idea from the start even though it's subject to change in various degrees.

I believe (1-3) addresses your concerns about regret to commission of a startup. In terms of whether a startup makes you unemployable, I do not see why a startup would bar you from further employment. Potential employers could point to the fact that there may be a hole in your CV where you weren't employed for a year or two, but you can easily describe your startup experiences and couple that explanation with why that experience makes you more valuable as an employee. Remember, you still have to be able to speak on your good points with ease and decisiveness whether or not you've engaged in a startup.

(b0ttler0cket):

This is a good question. I looked at mailboxapp.com and I noticed a few things right away. 1. It's beautiful to look at.

2. It's simple. It's easy to understand. 6 words describes each of it's selling points. This is important from a marketing perspective. It's the difference between marketing a super-specific product targeted especially for hackers and a product that everyone can use and understand. One is more likely to gain popular attention.

3. They did something similar to Groupon, where they created a mechanism that encouraged (in Groupon's cased "forced") people to begin discussing their product in a natural way. In Mailbox' case, they created a reservation list. I'm not sure if this was entirely necessary, but it seems to be talked about a lot, and it has the effect of reassuring potential users that the product is worth it. This is so important, especially for a startup that claims to reinvent an age old system such as email, which has been around since before AOL. When a potential user sees that X users already reserved the app, the user believes he/she has actually stumbled upon something useful, especially when they see also the Y users that will reserve it after them (another feature mailboxapp wisely included). By showing the Y people behind, the app is implying that there are a limited number of spaces. Potential users see X and say "huh, it's worth it" then see Y and say "oh I better get it now." That's how people get enticed to get the app and tell their friends "before it's too late." Besides, "reservations" are always for something important; dinners, Broadway shows. That facet of this mechanism shouldn't be ignored either.

4. Judging by the number of articles that pop up after search, mailboxapp also has good PR. Funny enough, the reservation mechanism is so interesting that most headlines start with how many reservations mailboxapp has. It's an especially good marketing tool when you can break some key marks "half a million," "one million," "two million reservations."

5. I see that it's also been bought by Dropbox. That also creates good publicity, and it may also be a big reason that there's been so much good press about mailboxapp.

:) Hope that helped. I'll keep looking so if I think of or see anything else, I'll make sure to include it. :)

-

Re:Ask HN: How can I "test" this idea? on Thursday April 04, 2013 @09:57AM (#5492646)
(b0ttler0cket):

Bhargav,

I want to start out by saying this is a cool idea. Other people have commented that it's not necessary or that you're building a platform on an industry that's beginning to decay. These positions might be true, but think about this as a first step. You already know this is not the prize idea, so where could you go from here? I'm curious to think of what you could come up with. I already have a few ideas in mind. Let's see if they're similar.

Re:Ask HN: Resources for Studying Multivariable Calculus? on Wednesday April 03, 2013 @10:37PM (#5490638)
1. I think the MIT response is a very good place to start, as I also used it (along with Khan) to do well during high school exams. I would also recommend as a further study aid

(http://tutorial.math.lamar.edu/Classes/CalcIII/EqnsOfPlanes....).

I recommend this site because of its concise outlines. MIT OCW is very video based and time consuming (not bad, just a fact). If you want pure, streamlined info (preview, review), then that's what I'm suggesting it for.

2. In terms of a book (esp. a textbook), my experience is that the profusion of text is wearying. I did best when I study intensely for short bouts of time spread over a semester. I believe an outline is more conducive to this approach.

3. As a source for problems to verify her knowledge and to practice the thinking method, I would recommend

(http://people.math.gatech.edu/~cain/notes/calculus.html)

I'll continue to look. To be honest, however, I have a feeling that the textbook has largely been replaced in favor of more readily accessible information online. Having one seems essential since it's the norm, but I think the online sites dedicated to teaching calculus3 are better suited.