News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

awestruckshoe

Re:A better way to divide the pie on Sunday March 20, 2022 @02:22PM (#30745174)
Thanks for the more concrete example—the pizza situation in the article seemed really contrived and unintuitive to me! One question this leaves me with and I don’t think the article addresses is what happens when losses are sustained when collaborating. Your stock example provides a good basis for an exploration of this question.

Say A puts $4000 in and B puts $2000 in with the expectation that they will double their money, but instead they lose it all. By the procedure outlined in article, the “pie” worth -$6000 would be evenly distributed, meaning both A and B would have to pay $3000. So A ends up with $1000 and B ends up with -$1000. This seems especially punitive to B, and they end up in a worse place than they would have with what the article calls the “power” arrangement, under which they would have $0 after losing only $2000 instead of $3000.

I’m curious about how many weaker parties continue to favor the “pie” method when losses are divided the same way as gains—-my intuition is that a “pie”-style deal is typically reached only when there is an almost-certain probability of gain, but I’m curious about how negotiators actually behave!