News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

atpalmer

Exactly what salawat said. The 10x coder isn't the "hotshot" type. They're 10x because they build systems well enough to deliver 10x the features, 10x the reliability, etc., etc.

What isn't well understood is that software is never fully spec-ed out. No matter how hard some businesses may try, only the coder is in the position to find corner cases, unspecified cases, cases that "shouldn't happen" (but can), and just bugs in the spec. It's unrealistic to build a quality system without a feedback loop between the people writing the spec and the people coding the spec. Both sides have to be smart and engaged.

There's certainly nothing wrong with the article. I didn't see it taking a point-of-view on who is and isn't to blame. It's telling factual information, which is relevant to the story of what happened, and you can make your own judgments.

The article you just read told you that the teams working on critical software have to be cheap, not good. That's not "just rabble-rousing." That's a scandal.

As you say, you're commenting without having any experience with the issue, but, as you can imagine, there's very little overlap between cheap and good.

throwawayMUSE is clearly right. These firms are playing the same game as used car salesmen--selling you junk that won't make it off the lot, all for $9/hr. It's true even for non-critical .NET apps that the business is getting ripped off. In mission critical systems, it's literally life and death. Sounding the alarm doesn't warrant dismissive sarcasm.