all_rights_rsvd
all_rights_rsvd on Hacker News
Re:GitHub Copilot as open source code laundering?
on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @09:57AM (#27688581)
So don't clone it, read it online. I reserve all rights, but I do give license to my host to make a "copy" to let you view it. I do that specifically to prevent non-biological entities like corporations or AI from using my code. If you're a biological entity, I specify you can email me to get a license for my code for a specific, defined purpose. I have a conversation with that person, then I send them a record number and the terms of my license for them in which I grant some rights which I had reserved.
Also, in your example, the copyright for the book or dvd is for the content, not the physical item. You can do anything you want with that item but not the content. My code is similar, I'm licensing my provider to serve you a visual representation of the files so you can experience the content, not giving you a license to run that code or use it otherwise.
Re:GitHub Copilot as open source code laundering?
on Wednesday June 30, 2021 @09:36AM (#27688344)
I post my code publicly, but with an "all rights reserved" licence. I don't mind everyone reading my code freely, but you can't use it for anything but learning. If I found out they were ingesting my code I would be angry. It's like training your replacement. I don't use GitHub, anyways, but now I'll definitely never even think about it.