News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

acidoverride

Re:Credit Card Fraud and an Algorithm on Friday May 20, 2022 @09:26PM (#31454473)
3 digit code check can not be cracked, with or without ML. You need other methods to verify if the code is working for a particular card number, most of which require trial(and error) payments.

Furthermore, it is plausible that a credit card fraudster keeps notes on, well..., credit cards. Guy could have been old school skimming the card numbers and CVV from purchases at his newspaper stand.

Re:Credit Card Fraud and an Algorithm on Friday May 20, 2022 @09:13PM (#31454393)
There exists no algorithm to calculate CVV from card number. The article also does not claim this.

> In other notes, he had left a record of how he had managed to obtain the security codes of the credit cards

> just a matter of time before someone gets severe complications for whatever outcome your program

If you are going to indirectly call someone out for publishing code which you deem severely detrimental to human health, you better back your stuff up.

> You have a false negative? Big problem

How does one get a false negative from multi-class probabilities? There aren't any...

> you just gave someone worse treatment options (if lucky) or led to someone being diagnosed too late and potentially getting metastasized breast cancer. Those bone metastases are quite painful, you know.

An image is already checked by a doctor, before given to the patient. A "False negative" then, is simply the doctor saying they are OK, and the ML confirming this, while both missing cancer. If doctor said, not OK, then no patient will take an OK from a website and be diagnosed too late. The last sentence is needlessly spiteful. I hope I misunderstood the intent of it.

> False positives are even worse, because they are far far far more likely to happen in practice. [...] I speak from experience that this WILL lead to the patient going to the doctor, and the doctor, seeing these very strong words, might want to take a biopsy to confirm the malignancy.

If doctor says OK, but my automated second opinion says not OK, then I go back to the doctor, and the doctor will either sooth my worries, explaining why the patch is benign. This is the desired outcome for my health. Or the doctor will second-guess their diagnosis, and perform, with my permission, more thorough tests. If tests come back OK, this will sooth my worries and the doctor's worries, and all will be fine. If tests come back not OK, then the application helped save my life.

There is zero reason to believe this app will bamboozle doctors into spending 1000s of dollars over nothing.

> If the tool is not for diagnostical purposes, it's not doing a whole lot in fighting cancer as it is just a play thing then.

This does not follow. There is a significant contribution with this app for fighting and raising awareness of cancer. Low-expertise hospitals use it as a diagnostics aid. People reported getting a second opinion from this app, returning to the hospital, and finding cancer early.

> At the moment, it's more like hindering cancer by taking resources from people who need them and giving them to people who don't need them.

Yes, it really seems you are deeming this app both severely dangerous and hindering cancer research. Without any solid (ML) reasoning and plenty of non-sequiturs. I'd suggest that even if you continue to hold such views, that you apologize to a fellow researcher.

Source: citizen scientist who open-sourced data analysis tools with disclaimers, now widely used for cancer screening, precision medicine, and improving chemo-therapy.

> a case study for AI ethics classes

What is unethical about this citizen science project? What is ethical about keeping it only for yourself, and not sharing it with the world?

You are saying you have the expertise to build a similar product, but releasing it would mean the worst fear of your community?

> people will recklessly apply ML

What are the indications that this is a reckless application of ML?

> How many people went to this website, uploaded images, were told were ok and didn't follow up?

Common sense dictates exactly zero. Their follow up was taking their images and getting an automated second opinion. Either a doctor already deemed them OK, or a doctor deemed them not OK, in which case, they would not rely on a second opinion, to think they are suddenly OK.

> How many were told they have cancer and insisted on procedures they didn't need?

Again, exactly zero. The app returns probabilities not binary diagnostics. No hospital would do anti-cancer procedures on a patient without cancer, even when they insist, because some website, friend, or religious leader told them so.

> The website is totally unaccountable.

Good. Or make the good-faith open-source project accountable and liable? That would simply mean shutting it down. No more diagnostics help for low-expertise hospitals: not good at all.

> Totally without any of the most basic ethical standards in medicine.

List a basic ethical standard in medicine which this project runs afoul of.

> basic human rights for patients

What right is that? The right not to upload your images to a site of your choosing? I thought human rights include self-determination, and keeping possession of your imaging to do however you see fit.

> In the US this would have been shut down by the FDA immediately.

But is that a good, ethical thing? Or simply that red tape and authority in US does not allow for such projects?

> We should not be celebrating this unethical "science" that doesn't meet even the most basic of scientific standards or ethical standards.

You should not talk about ethics or science, when you did not do even a proper evaluation of the work of a fellow scientist.

> I can't believe this is getting upvoted here.

Awaiting your work on cancer research and ML. Post it here. If devoid of ethical issues, and strongly scientific, it will also be upvoted and celebrated. Or is your major contribution going to be a snipe at someone who actually contributed?

Re:CDC Alerts Providers to Hepatitis Cases of Unknown Origin on Saturday April 23, 2022 @12:20PM (#31135631)
It would likely backfire, but not by literally shooting yourself in the foot.

If the virus is indiscriminate, and still useful as a weapon, then the host country weaponizing it, will have an anti-dote or vaccination at the ready. When the virus finds its way back to your country, your citizens are already immune.

But coronavirus can be made to discriminate. Militaries have been researching gene-targeted coronaviruses. They can just plug the data people volunteer to Chinese DNA-testing companies into a supercomputer and create a virus which discriminates on race and age, before deciding who to make really ill.

Re:CDC Alerts Providers to Hepatitis Cases of Unknown Origin on Saturday April 23, 2022 @12:12PM (#31135563)
I do not think they are saying the vaccination of the children is the cause. They even mention that vaccines are not approved.

Instead, they correctly write about how the WHO tried to block the "infodemic" that SARS is airborne, because it was not feasible to do much about that which would not be very costly, and may increase panic, which makes people harder to manage and control.

We do not know the effects of long COVID on children, even though health officials opened back up the schools. Again, there are other concerns there than your personal or family's health: if you do not open the schools, then parents can not get to work, and hospitals and police collapse.

From SARS-1, we know that SARS can cause long-lasting kidney damage. But nobody wants to come out and say: "we send your children back to school without masks, and while we said children do not get severely ill from COVID, the effects of long COVID in children was not possible to investigate, nor (cost-)effectively manage.". That makes a lot of sense.

Re:Increase in hepatitis of unknown origin in children on Saturday April 23, 2022 @02:19AM (#31131902)
> Vaccinated people shed mRNA into the surrounding environment.

They do. But in tiny enough amounts not to make people sick.

Vaccinated people do shed virus enough to make surrounding people sick, with unvaccinated people at greater risk, especially when these vaccinated do not mask, or do not get sick enough to isolate.

This topic and any discussion around it was carefully demonized, making it so even people like Luigi Warren could not get the information out that mRNA can be shed by the vaccinated.

The fervent anti-vaccination activists only got more fuel for their fires, with officials downplaying any talk of shedding or ADE. And then they blamed their rhetoric on the vaccine hesitant.

> COVID isn't even caused by a virus.

It took a lot of decades for scientists to come to the same conclusion about the Spanish "flu" pandemic.

The snake venom thing is of course an extreme outlier. If that is what you think you are "up against" with the anti-vaxxers and vaccination hesitant, you can not understand the merits of the other camp's views. The very fact check for the snake venom thing has this to say:

> But, as we’ve explained before, scientists in China first isolated the virus that causes COVID-19 on Jan. 7, 2020. Scientists at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in the U.S. then isolated the virus later that month, from a patient who was diagnosed with the disease in Washington state. And scientists in other countries have also isolated the virus. The World Health Organization announced the official name of the virus — SARS-CoV-2 — on Feb. 11, 2020.

Do you really think scientists in China first isolated the virus in 2020? It seems a rather definitive and factual claim, certainly welcomed by the Chinese regime and the narrative they want to support. Head over to the 4chan archive to see multiple posts discussing isolating a novel coronavirus with weird characteristics in the late months of 2019. It is there, and harder to argue against, and quite enlightening to say the least.

Re:CDC Alerts Providers to Hepatitis Cases of Unknown Origin on Saturday April 23, 2022 @01:19AM (#31131600)
Post already flagged. Just posted a theory which was asked for. Neither asked for flags.

I am not even implying it comes from the vaccine. But we have a data point where the Russian vaccine batches had replicating adenovirus, with projections of liver damage. I do not see why a sick person could not spread that to other persons.

Or it could have been a transfection due to co-infection of SARS and adenovirus, where adenovirus picked up part of the genetic code of SARS.

My theory is that it is related to either the COVID outbreak, or the resulting vaccination efforts (which not all countries followed strict protocols). Seems too coincidental to get an adenovirus outbreak shortly after a pandemic. But could be: a new adenovirus.