_hackerman
I think calling open source "greedy" is an antithesis and a sentiment that if repeated enough burns out the best maintainers. They do not work for the software's adopters and it is their fair right to ask for money if they spend time on doing work that only benefits others.
I recommend reading a bit about open source and expectation management: https://mikemcquaid.com/2018/03/19/open-source-maintainers-o...
In any case, it is unfortunate that the interaction did not meet your expectations. Keycloak is a great project, with a great community, and if it solves your needs you have made the correct choice!
So basically Ory Hydra is the most stable and we did not have any big breaking changes (maybe a CLI command arg renamed) in the last 2 years iirc.
Cloud service is planned for a private beta in Q1 2021 (lmk if you are interested). Public release probably end of 2021 I think!
> Also I have to say that about a year ago I wanted to teach myself about OAuth and I find almost every online guide and book to be terrible (and usually trying to sell me something). Two things finally put it all together for me: reading the OIDC spec and reading the Hydra & Kratos code and docs.
Awesome! I was in the exact same boat. Usually OAuth2 is a marketing thing for companies that are closed source, because it is the only "open" thing they can offer. Then they bend the protocol to fit the actual use case - which is sign in, registration, and so on. OAuth2 was never intended to be a protocol for "login". It's a protocol for Developer X to get access to your Facebook Fotos.
My personal goal with Ory is to educate people around security (good security is easy, not hard) and clean up the misconceptions. I hope this helps the developer ecosystem become more secure and better educated as a whole!
- Login, registration, mfa, user management, password change, account recovery, ... - Ory Kratos: http://github.com/ory/kratos
- Permission management, roles, who is allowed to do what - Ory Keto: http://github.com/ory/keto
- OAuth2, OpenID Connect Provider that you "connect" to your user management (e.g. Ory Kratos) - Ory Hydra: http://github.com/ory/hydra
- A "middleware" which checks if requests are authenticated (who is the caller?) and authorized (is the caller allowed to do that) - Ory Oathkeeper: http://github.com/ory/oathkeeper
It's a bit like lego where the other projects are more like the full car you buy. The car might use little fuel but it's slow and you can't change that. The lego parts you can combine any way you want.
Plus, Ory is written in Go and we aim for supporting planet-scale distributed data stores to support global deployments with low latency, and other cool stuff!
The last point, we are actually building out a cloud service (think CockroachCloud without the licensing issues), which means that you don't buy a support contract from IBM but instead get everything with a few clicks! Kinda like Auth0, Okta, or Firebase - but with everything open source (maybe like sentry.io?)
1. Almost never - it's a lot of work to get from a library to a server that has a strong persistence layer, is scalable, has all the management around it (e.g. write and create clients). Also, upgrading a server is much easier than upgrading a library! 2. We plan to have ORY Kratos v0.6 out of alpha (what we call sandbox) and in "incubating" status. That means that we feel confident that APIs won't change as much an more but there is still risk that you have to deal with some breaking changes. For version 1.0 it is probably going to land in 2022, as we usually stay 1 year in sandbox, 1 year in incubating and if everything has stabilized go to stable. Having said that, you can still use this stuff in prod. For us, alpha/sandbox just means: "Careful, there will be breaking changes!". But we never release insecure, untested or half-baked stuff.
I started the project Ory Hydra back in 2015 as a side project, and it has now become a full time job with a dedicated team! Ory Hydra is used at a lot of companies and we have since started with some other projects such as ORY Kratos (https://github.com/ory/kratos).
If you have any questions regarding Hydra, Ory, Golang, or open source - I am more than happy to answer!
edit:// Signing off - if you have any questions for maintainers feel free to check out the ory slack channel or ask on the GitHub discussions board!