News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

WillusFredus

Re:Write HTML Right on Friday June 10, 2022 @12:48PM (#31696552)
> There was never a well-substantiated argument for the alleged harm of layout tables.

What was the best argument that you can recall? What were some of the bad ones? What does "harm" mean in this context?

> because the dependencies between HTML structure and styling are just too many and too strong.

Which dependencies? What would a structure/styling language combination look like that that lacked or had weak dependencies?

Re:Write HTML Right on Friday June 10, 2022 @12:46PM (#31696521)
> the idea persists to this day despite its near complete failure to pay off significantly in nearly twenty years

I am not clear on exactly what "the idea" refers to, perhaps you could clarify. Also, how has the idea "completely failed"? And what would complete success look like?

Re:Write HTML Right on Friday June 10, 2022 @12:15PM (#31696154)
I agree that a tree structure can work well for mapping UIs, but HTML does not. It was specifically design as a textual markup language. Its role has been expanded, but it has been done so poorly.

What really needs to happen it a separation of HTML from UI markup elements. HTML will be used solely for textual markup and a new markup language can be used for UIs. This would allow us to return to a proper separation of concerns.