Ruuttu2
Here's a quote from Niklas himself: "there is absolutely no good reason to create a calculator with CSS only, I just did it for the kicks."
The project was posted deliberately as a joke and I was commenting on that. The submitter was saying "Look how awfully this can be done LOL" and I responded by appreciating that it was indeed awful. The meaning is clear and it's not a hurtful message just because it includes the word "awful" twice. You must consider the content of the message and not just judge it because a negative word is used.
"That is not constructive feedback" you say. You're right, it isn't. And that's fine because the project wasn't posted to receive constructive feedback. The author is never going to touch that project ever again. It's a joke. What am I gonna say, "You might want to increase the contrast of the buttons in your completely-ridiculous-project-you-built-just-for-laughs before you throw it away"? The author doesn't care and nobody cares.
I know you're not gonna agree. You've clearly made up your mind already. You've even done what very few sensible people would and admitted it yourself. Whatever. I just want everyone else to understand that I'm not a bad guy.
I'm not a bad guy.
The person who made that calculator wasn't inexperienced. He knew that building a calculator with CSS is objectively a bad idea. He built it anyway just to see how ludicrous it would end up being, for laughs. That's truly the real hacker spirit.
In this context my comment stood for "Well done, but you know that was a complete waste of time". Or as one of his friends said on his Google Plus page: "What a crazy hack!" https://plus.google.com/115030581977322198102/posts/Qo6T85W8... That's not a putdown. It's in a way a compliment.
I would also argue that most users on HN want to get negative feedback but that's a separate issue.
I'm really sorry that you criticized me publicly without allowing me to defend myself so I had to create this other account. Sorry about that.