Melcher
I would say this also hinges on the fact that when we're young we go through a lot of quick bursts of change, think of yourself in grade school, high school, etc. You grow quite substantially both physically and personally. That growth slows down, you establish yourself, who you really are, you 'stick' with a core group of friends in most cases and you generally, as people say, "settle down".
My guess is when DVDs first became the craze there were only a handful of titles, as more titles were added people bought more - often going out to buy their favorites and classics for the sake of nostalgia. In this way Hollywood was making money by just re-releasing a lot of old content.
Now that all that 'catching up' has occurred and customers have already gone out and bought their favorite films, only new releases remain - and those are either a. underwhelming or b. not yet 'classic' status enough to bother owning.