News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

MasterOfMagic

Re:How is Apple's pay to provide content model legal? on Wednesday February 16, 2011 @04:09PM (#2228314)
http://segaretro.org/SEGA_vs._Accolade

SEGA only wanted licensed developers to develop for the Mega Drive, so they required a piece of code in order for a game to boot. This piece of code included the SEGA trademark. The thought was that if any unlicensed games appeared, SEGA could sue for trademark violation. SEGA sued when Accolade started producing unlicensed carts for the Mega Drive. The courts ruled against SEGA saying that since the code was functional, not expressive, there was no trademark violation.

Re:How is Apple's pay to provide content model legal? on Wednesday February 16, 2011 @04:04PM (#2228286)
They sell Visual Studio, don't they? It's not the only toolchain for Windows, but it's likely the most popular toolchain.

It's Microsoft's OS. The reason that they got in trouble is that they unfairly used their market position to kick competitors (Lotus, Netscape, Novell) out. I doubt it would be illegal if they decided to charge everyone equally based on either units shipped or royalty.

Re:How is Apple's pay to provide content model legal? on Wednesday February 16, 2011 @04:01PM (#2228275)
Just having a monopoly is not illegal. It is only when this monopoly position is abused that it is illegal.

Apple does not have a monopoly over the mobile phone space, and therefore I highly doubt what they are doing is illegal.