News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

MartinMansson

Re:Medieval trade networks on Monday May 28, 2018 @02:04PM (#17173825)
all roads that are depicted as named roads do have their names on the map. Azalay in west Africa is one example.
Re:Medieval trade networks on Monday May 21, 2018 @06:32PM (#17122399)
I understand that errors like this can make one doubt the whole product. The content of the map is not made up and very well researched. The fact that i chose to name the settlements like i did (didn't have to be major, but notable or strategic) does not erase its educational value. i causght myself actually defending the location of sarai-juk, and not sarai. You are completely correct in the instance of Sarai. This will have to be corrected in future editions.

Instead of putting the settlements in quotes i should rather find another way of describing their lack of known name. There were trade links and settlements that were involved in international trade but that remains unnamed, simply referring to areas or islands. I wanted to depict these links as well.

The objective with the map is to not start from a smaller part of the world, but to remedy the fact that the maps out there are either local and detailed, or global and general. I want to strike a balance between the two, and the only way i can do that is to publish and republish my map for constant reviews, which is why i appreciate your effort of correcting the map.

This is a side passion project of mine that has been revised constantly during 2 years, there are other versions of this map out there significantly less accurate. And i plan to keep updating this project, because i think its usefulness definitely outweighs the drawbacks of small errors. Spelling errors are however a big drawback, and as you say, will make the map look less reliable.

You said earlier that i missed some major trade routes, do you have any of these in mind that i can work with?

I don't know the guy who put this map up here for crowdfunding. I was just told by someone that it was up here. I just like to track down wherever this map goes to see who comments on it in order for me to improve it. I give this map out for free to anyone who asks and have no commercial interest.

Thank you again for your response.

Re:Medieval trade networks on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:24PM (#17121031)
Saint-Omer was heavily active in the wool and clothing trade at the end of the 12th century, it also was situated closer to the coast at this time. Sometimes, sadly, i have had to omit some locations in order to not clutt the map too much. Maybe i should look over the Calais region again. The port from France to England was probably in the Wissant region, as the Via Francigena went through here. I did not have a source of what city/port existed here at the time, some sources cites Sombre as an existing port. Calais existed during this time frame, but the extent to which it was used have been hard for me to establish. Saint-Omer was the only trading settlement i really had any good claims putting on the map.
Re:Medieval trade networks on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:11PM (#17120920)
This is not on purpose. This is a misspelling on my part. fast fingers.
Re:Medieval trade networks on Monday May 21, 2018 @03:10PM (#17120906)
I've had trouble finding sources this early when it comes to Portugal concerning trade. Portugal seem to have been more involved starting from when the strait of Gibraltar opened up to christians and ships from the Mediterranean sea could sail up to the north sea. An opportunity in itself that seem to have had a negative impact of the trade fairs of inland france and germany. Although, i'm unsure to what extent this damage had.
Re:Medieval trade networks on Monday May 21, 2018 @02:56PM (#17120790)
Hello, i'm the author of the map. Sarai has been suggested to have existed before the mongols arrived, and was a strategic location on the route between europe and asia before the height of the "north" northern silk road.

The reason for why Arkhangelsk is there has been explained by earlier replies.

Names are misspelled. Sometimes it was my fingers that moved too fast, and sometimes i've experienced sources spelling names differently.

If i have omitted significant trade routes i would be happy to receive some notice.

This is a continuous passion project of mine, and i'm happy to improve it. I have already gotten a lot of good feedback, all from cities being placed in the wrong order to misspellings.

The purpose of the map is to make it interesting and engaging for people to look at. It's also meant as a road map to navigate the trade/communication networks of the old world that you otherwise could only get from overly general maps. It's a mammoth task, and i appreciate all help i can get.