News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

LifeExpectancy

Re:Widening Gap in U.S. Life Expectancy on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @11:39AM (#14359504)
Thank you. I agree with many of your points. Of course, I know about the discussion of (maximum) life span and also of life expectancy. And, obviously, the maximum and the expected value (life expectancy) of a random variable is something different.

I also agree with your statement that life expectancy depended heavily on how many people die young. Absolutely. But what is not correct is the statement about the number of centenarians. Please check, for instance, the Human Mortality Database yourself at www.mortality.org to see how quickly the number of them is growing. This does not only have something to do with larger birth cohorts entering those ages but also because of major reductions in mortality among people aged 80-100. And I would be very curious if you were able to provide a scientific reference to your statement that human longevity (do you mean maximum life span?) has been around 80 years for thousands of years. Do you agree with me (if you refer to maximum life span) that this is different now?

And -- as you say correctly -- I also agree with you that it would be advisable not to use vague terms. And in my opinion longevity is a vague term since some people use it for life expectancy others for life span. So it would be better if people use those clearly defined concepts to avoid confusion.

My comment about "no one dies of old age" refers to the fact that a certain cause (ICD 10 code) has to be entered on the death certificate. But I also agree with you here: the precision of this information at very high ages might be problematic due to multimorbidity. Your question concerning the "correct term..." I do not want to claim that I know the correct term. In my experience, people usually differentiate between senescent mortality and non-senescent mortality.

Final remark: It seems you are familiar with James Fries' influential paper from 1980 in NEJM [0] since he is talking about "ideal conditions" and "natural deaths", which is pretty close to what you write in your last sentence. :-)

[0] http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM198007173030304

Re:Widening Gap in U.S. Life Expectancy on Wednesday May 17, 2017 @03:16AM (#14356281)
I was just a reader so far but I had to register now. As someone who works full-time in this field: - You are right about the definition of life expectancy. - I have never ever heard this definition of longevity. It is sometimes used as a synonym for life expectancy. - No one dies of old age.