Firgof
Regarding the sales I have to say: The increase in traffic is absolutely astounding. We made more at $3.50 in one day than we made at $20 over many, many, months. It was essentially four months of income in a night. If it wasn't super-profitable for everyone else, why in the world would they keep doing it sale after sale?
We're a tiny little niche game, so there's that as well. I don't know what you mean about it not being profitable. If your game is unappealing and you don't market it at all, sure, I can see that. We spent $10 total on our marketing for the game and that mainly went to registering a SA account.
If they're really hard pressed for money and they've got a great idea, how hard could it possibly be to get a $100 kickstarter done in a month?
$100 may be a lot to someone who is homeless but if they've got a solid idea, then I'm sure there's enough people out there to punch you up to $100 and beyond.