News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

ElKowar

Re:Eww: Programmable Widgets for Linux on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @07:30AM (#35712049)
I've definitely considered it, and I do see the points of yuck either becoming a bad, turing complete lisp, or being just,... not powerful enough. However, I have two main counterpoints to the idea of turning it into a library for some scripting language like lua:

- The original goal of eww was to be two-dimensional polybar with support for full visuals and CSS, rather than just colored text. This means that my target audience, at least initially, was also more the polybar crowd than the awesomeWM crowd. Eww aims to be usable without really needing to know how to program, and aims to provide declarative UI description language that reduces complexity of state management and logic as much as possible. This is, arguably, a goal I've at least somewhat reached -- primarily given the fact that eww DID grow quite fast, and did enable lots of people to do more interesting UI designs than other projects (such as AwesomeWM) did. "Widgets for everyone" is a tagline I don't wanna leave, and thus requiring users to do full-on scripting is not something I'd wanna do easily.

- if you remove yuck and it's state management architecture from eww, you'll be left with quite little. Thus, there would at that point be little added value over existing GTK wrappers. The thing that makes eww appealing (at least IMO) is that it does simplify lots of the most commonly needed things down to a very simple state and UI structure, and provides a great iteration-cycle with great error messages. This would be very hard to keep when turning it into a regular, more imperative library

Re:Eww: Programmable Widgets for Linux on Wednesday April 26, 2023 @07:24AM (#35712009)
Superficially, it is similar to conky in concept, but with very different primary points of focus. whilst conky excells at having lots of info on your desktop in the background, eww might not be optimal for that. On the other hand, eww is generally a lot easier to get visually appealing main-point-of-focus widgets in, for overlay dashboards, media/volume controls and of course bars. Eww was and is generally designed to be more or less "two-dimensional polybar", both in its original design of widgets and the state architecture.

Being written using GTK and thus also styled in GTK CSS makes a big impact here, of course

Re:Eww: Programmable Widgets for Linux on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @11:46AM (#35702100)
Yes! It works both on X and on Wayland, and should support basically any DE, WM and compositor out there. Note that there are a few exceptions: As far as I'm aware, GNOME on wayland is not going to work well, as GNOME doesn't implement the necessary wayland extension protocols eww relies on to position its windows
Re:Eww: Programmable Widgets for Linux on Tuesday April 25, 2023 @11:45AM (#35702086)
Note that this is primarily a syntactical choice -- there isn't _currently_ much in the configuration language that actually resembles the functionality from regular lisp languages. I've been thinking quite a bit about how I could make use of the s-expression based syntax to turn yuck into a more feature-rich, actual lisp language, without completely going out-of-scope ^^