News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

D_u20ac35_ming

I'm happy to read Huixiang's text, in that they are clear in explaining his PIs transgressions. I'm in a similar situation where my PI is threatening to kick me out of the lab or fail me after 5 years in the program after bringing him data better than all of his last 5 students combined. So I definitely know where the ECE candidate is coming from.

But the PhD candidate needed to step away from his data/project and instead familiarize himself with his options. Or befriend someone who could. This is really where hyper specialization breaks down, in that you get the "free rider" problem of people abusing the process (e.g. congressman) to parasite and bastardize others work. Now the PhD student has to become a master in a second subject (the law) to preserve the huge investment in the first subject (science). Needless to say, this ends badly a lot of the time.

It's worth pointing out that as a foreigner, he was even more isolated than an American student. Because I myself have received stellar advice from graduate student Union professionals from a university in a state far away. This student likely has several barriers, cultural and others, keeping him from effeciently defending his rights. Think about this the next time you hear about academia's obsession with foreign students