BrinDaxter
Re:Ask HN: Why don't websites show password requirements at the login ...
on Tuesday December 12, 2017 @12:35PM (#15907536)
In my experience, it boils down to these assumptions:
1: if your site is uncluttered -- that is, it hides non-essential information -- it will be more appealing to the user;
2: if your site is following practices common to other sites, the average user will have already learned those practices before coming to your site;
3: if a specific user demonstrates a need for guidance/non-essential information, that information should be made explicitly available.
Applied to password requirements:
- Show the password field without requirements (uncluttered initial state)
- If they enter a valid password, all is well (happy path)
- If they enter an invalid password, surface the requirements (explicit guidance)