News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

2oi03i9fhujcnd

I disagree completely with what you said. It trivializes the personal pain that depressed people feel.

But let's explore your reasoning further:

Can you please explain to me how sending Bill Zeller to a war-torn country would have helped him deal with the sexual abuse that he experienced?

Down vote all you want, but it goes to show how we treat people with mental illness. Hey, someone has it worse than you, so suck it up.

Well let's disprove this path mathematically. YC would like that. I will prove by contradiction.

1. maxklein's assertion is that someone has it worse than you so you shouldn't kill yourself.

2. That means the person with the worst life in the world CAN kill himself.

3. Following that, the new worst life person can kill himself.

4. Then a new person. This can continue until one person is left on the earth. Does he kill himself?

There are different ways life can be bad. Living in Iraq, Afghanistan, or Congo is perhaps one way.

Oh wow that sounds great. Need a first customer? Can you now explain to me how that helps me deal with the guilt of my friends dying there?

Thanks.

Re:RIP Bill Zeller on Saturday January 08, 2011 @12:00AM (#2082293)
What you said is exactly the problem. It isn't for you to decide what is a big or small secret. If a person wants something kept quiet, that should be enough. The receiver's own view of what should be spread is immaterial.
Re:RIP Bill Zeller on Friday January 07, 2011 @02:21AM (#2078916)
Good point distinguishing between rumor mill and personal trauma.

I think that might only affect the number of people that are told, though. Rumor mill will spread like wildfire. Trauma will be told to one other person, and the one other person will probably keep it to himself.

It is possible that the first person won't disclose further. Bill seems to have made a general social commentary about finding that person is very difficult. He couldn't trust his family. He tried friends and that didn't work. Counselors wouldn't work.

How many people do you have to try? Many people say try until you die of natural causes. Others say this was enough.

Re:RIP Bill Zeller on Friday January 07, 2011 @02:07AM (#2078890)
That is true, it certainly is possible. I can't actually prove the absolute case.

But I do believe that it is much more probable that everyone has a personal outlet with whom they speak. Life is hard. (Can I even say that absolutely? Although completely foreign to me, I suppose there are people out there that don't have hardships in life.) People need to vent to someone, share some close or special with someone, and make a connection.

Without that people explode. This is one way people without that outlet explode.

Re:RIP Bill Zeller on Friday January 07, 2011 @01:54AM (#2078863)
It isn't for the secret-listener to decide what is worthwhile to hold in confidence. A small secret shouldn't be disclosed just because the person that heard it thinks that it isn't worth keeping secret.

Besides, I don't think contemporary community standards would consider coming out as gay as being a small secret.

Generalizing further, it really isn't fair for me to classify any of these as big or small. One person may consider coming out as gay as no big deal and hide past sexual abuse, while another may consider disclosing past sexual abuse as no big deal and not disclose sexual orientation. It isn't for me to decide which is bigger than the other.

Re:RIP Bill Zeller on Friday January 07, 2011 @12:24AM (#2078695)
Thank you for your kind words.

To understand where Bill is coming from you really need to hop into his shoes. He tried to trust people but they violated that trust. Regardless of the reasons for doing that, they didn't keep his secret. What he told them was much less important to him than his ultimate secret. If they can't keep those smaller secrets, why can they keep the big one?

For better or worse all of the other things he told people were tests. Who can keep this secret? You, ok, I will let you in on a little more, then a little more, then a little more. But no one kept all of them, so no one could complete the journey to the last one.

Bill had no reason to trust a doctor. Everything in his life confirmed the exact opposite - no one is to be trusted, everyone will tell your secrets. Everyone always has that one person that they want to tell, but no worries, it's ok, that person won't tell anyone.

Yup, but everyone has that person. And unfortunately for Bill, he wasn't able to find someone to tell, and have their "one person" be Bill, thus keeping his secret between two, and only two, people in this world.

Re:RIP Bill Zeller on Thursday January 06, 2011 @09:58PM (#2078373)
Bill wanted to tell someone, but only one person. The problem is that you can't tell one person because everyone has someone else that they will tell. Someone always has a higher allegiance to another than you. Maybe it is different for married people, but then we get a chicken and egg problem. How can you find a partner to marry when issues like this, kept secret, keep you from having a long-term relationship?

He tried to trust people at Trinity but they spread his secrets. He knows that doctors and counselors have allowances for when they can disclose information. He probably floated personal information his whole life to people to see if they could be trusted. I bet each secret came back to him from another party. He couldn't find a person to trust so he didn't disclose his ultimate secret.

He only wanted 1 person. He could deal with 1. Maybe years later 2 people, but for now just 1. Not 1 in an anonymous posting online. Not 1 in a chat room. 1 right in front of you.

The problem is that there isn't 1. Some people can deal with that, being open and all. For some, the quest for 1 is the goal, and realization that there isn't 1 is hard to take. It doesn't help.

I read a lot of me in that letter. I am 29 now. Will I make it to 30? Yes. 35? Maybe. 40? ...