00000000swan
Does this also mean that the "big winners" will not come merely from a pool of what appear to be bad ideas, but from a subset of that pool: bad ideas put forth by founders the VC thinks are impressive? That too, seems somewhat obvious.
Taking it one step further, can you separate the "idea" from the "founder" in assessing the project's chances of being a "big winner"?
Maybe that was the goal of requesting that people should apply to YC even if they had no "idea".
After all, the supply of "bad ideas" is potentially limitless.
Assume you could separate the funding vehicle from the YC reputation, having it as a separate unassociated entity.
That is, assume the "reputational" cost could be managed. And no one would accuse you of being "insane".
I liked this essay. I think it's sufficiently honest.