It's not that what intelligence agencies do is morally OK, it's that it's practically necessary for a country not to be at a terrible disadvantage economically.
> So is there something which would not be appropriate if NSA did? Assassinate leaders, murdering school children, causing nuclear meltdowns... where is the line so we in the future can point to that whenever this kind of news pops up?
NSA does signals intelligence, not assassinations. I don't know what rules are in place as to what's OK in spying/sabotage and what isn't, but I imagine it's something not super unreasonable...
Fair enough. That means we should never have to take any talk of "free market" or its merits seriously. The whole "magic of the free market" always irritated me anyway, since there's never any account of information asymmetry. Clearly, large, multi-national corporations have a better idea of supply and demand than an isolated consumer does, even without help from a government spy agency.
Well, maybe this is splitting hairs, but...
https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/02/10/the-nsas-secre...
Yeah, but you see, when it comes to regular blood-and-flesh people, we (as a society, through courts) don't judge them based on whether their actions have been reasonable or not. We could, but the world would be very different. Having different standards for different people/organizations is plain hypocritical, undermines democracy and weakens civil society.
Having different legal standards for what a CIA agent operating in Pakistan can do and a civilian working in the US has absolutely nothing to do with democracy and civil society.
I don't know, I guess I would assume that anything goes in most situations. Having paid attention to what's been done in the past...
If you're talking about people violating organizational rules and abusing the tools provided to them to do their jobs, that's an issue that absolutely needs to be addressed, but it doesn't mean we should remove all situations where we trust anyone with power. People with power they might abuse are literally everywhere - sysadmins at telecom and tech companies have even more power than NSA agents to go through your personal affairs unnoticed (and probably go through fewer background checks). On-the-street LE officers have even more power than that by some measure, because they can physically detain and harm you with the tools provided to them by the state. Of course abuse is an issue that needs to be addressed, but taking away power for anyone that might abuse it is simply not a feasible answer at this point.
Also while you are at it, please read up who authorized the full take (which includes said ex-lover...).