News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:100% Unemployment: on keeping busy when the robots take over by rhino369 on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:05PM (#9066109)
Just because it happened twice--from ag to factories from factories to service--doesn't mean there will be a huge new need for employment. In the past, human consumption just increased. I'm not so sure there will be a need for all that much more consumption. If the promise of near human level AI occurs, we'd need to have exponential growth in consumption to keep up the pace.

Also, a lot of those jobs disappeared forever in the third world and never came back. Ag jobs were never really replaced with manufacturing job. Only now are some third world countries getting manufacturing jobs. If they are replaced with automated manufacturing those coding, engineering, and management jobs will go to the first world.

So maybe it works out for America and Europe. But someplace like Indonesia and India get permafucked yet again by a new industrial revolution.

Re:100% Unemployment: on keeping busy when the robots take over by nhaehnle on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:55PM (#9066054)
Agriculture provides for the basic needs of humans. What do humans do once their basic needs are met? Some of them go on to do meaningful things that expand the human condition, such as devoting themselves to the arts and the sciences. The vast majority of them turn to zero-sum status games.

This is a serious problem, because the more physical wealth can be provided by robots, the more those status games necessarily become about obtaining power over other humans. This puts capitalism, as an enabler of this kind of status games, on a path to escalating conflict not just with democracy but with human rights.

Of course, many would say that this is already happening. For now, the conflict is simply at a level where human rights violations and everything that goes with it can still be exported to third world countries.

Re:100% Unemployment: on keeping busy when the robots take over by TeMPOraL on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:05PM (#9066110)
Not only you have zero-sum status games, you have plain old zero-sum games, which do nothing but just waste resources. Prime examples: marketing, political campaigns. Every additional effort people put in those two basically goes to cancel-out the effort of everyone else, giving you a system in which you can waste infinite resources for no marginal gain.
Re:100% Unemployment: on keeping busy when the robots take over by wvenable on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:50PM (#9066027)
This argument keeps coming up. The problem is this is based on exactly one data point. So saying "historically..." is hardly relevant!

The automation that is happening now has never happened in the history of the human race. You simply cannot extrapolate from past events and say it'll be like that again.

Re:100% Unemployment: on keeping busy when the robots take over by poikniok on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:52PM (#9066036)
It is more based on thousands of years of data. Every generation likes to think that they are unique, and that "this time everything is different". In reality life will go on.
Re:100% Unemployment: on keeping busy when the robots take over by wvenable on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:56PM (#9066067)
I have no doubt that life will go on but that isn't the argument here. The argument is that while automation kills jobs in one area but create more in another. There's no logical basis for thinking that's a consistent pattern. Large scale mechanical automation is only a few hundred years old.
Re:100% Unemployment: on keeping busy when the robots take over by gutnor on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:17PM (#9066170)
There is little doubt that there is work for everyone. Problem is if there is profitable work for everyone.

For example, you will find countless people to help dig various archeological site, help processing the various museum collection still hidden in boxed, ...

Also "historically" is misleading. Historically the industrial revolution was one of the worst period to live - the conversion of those 90% to the industry was not a happy story. And the post-war golden age was after the worst wars ever.

We are also dealing with some hard limit this time. On the production side, we are hitting earth physical limit on about everything. Even on the consumer side, we are hitting some limit, even for virtual activities, there are only 24 hour a day for you to consume.

History is good to remind you to be optimistic. However, history is not a solution: some guy in 100 year may look back at this period as another great time in human history, but that's down to us find the details on how to achieve it.

Re:100% Unemployment: on keeping busy when the robots take over by craigyk on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @06:47PM (#9066008)
Yes, but automation is getting better. "Historically always been the case" is a deceptive panacea. It isn't inconceivable to imagine that it might start eating into knowledge-based work even more, continually shrinking the percentage of the population that is employable regardless of talent or education. Not that this is necessarily a bad thing (10 hour work weeks anyone?), unfortunately, the current world economy isn't set up to handle this transition well.
Re:100% Unemployment: on keeping busy when the robots take over by TeMPOraL on Tuesday February 17, 2015 @07:09PM (#9066136)
The difference is, previous automation replaced human muscle. Today's automation replaces human brain.

Of course, it does it gradually. So you see low-skilled jobs disappearing, and no useful jobs being created in their place. As this process continues, I expect we'll be facing a growing number of people trapped in poverty who have no means and abilities to retrain themselves for jobs with more skill requirements.