Maybe they are not out of your league. What makes you think they are?
If they are, is it even in a dimension that matters in a relationship?
If so, you can work towards getting up into their league.
What's the details?
I have never seen this actually work. I have failed doing it myself.
Sappiness is what girls want from the guys they are already head-over-heels attracted to. It does not work for converting a girl from neutral or slightly attracted into wanting to go with you.
The best thing to do is just to hang out with her casually, flirt, be playful, tease her, do active things, go for walks, have fun, and gradually escalate physically, escalate touching, escalate sexual innuendo in your conversation. If she reacts positively, escalate more, if not, then there is sometimes nothing you can do.
The best book I have read on this subject is "Models: Attract Women through Honesty" - http://www.amazon.com/Models-Attract-Women-Through-Honesty-e...
You could: - Write a script - Perhaps say you have feelings for her instead of dropping the L word. L is big. And I think it's hard to really make exist if you're not actually together for a while. - Make sure you're aware / able to control your breathing while you tell her. Will chill you out.