News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Twiddler 3 chording keyboard now available by bumbledraven on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @03:43PM (#8598023)
Chording keyboards [are] a poor idea that will never fly.

How then do you explain the success of stenotype keyboards, which use chording heavily? According to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stenotype, "a trained court reporter or closed captioner must write speeds of approximately 180, 200, and 225 words per minute (wpm) at very high accuracy." I don't believe any non-chording-keyboard users can sustain a rate of 225 wpm.

Related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8510409 ("Plover: Text to thought at 240 WPM")

It would be interesting to know if these high speeds be achieved with a non-chording keyboard using sequential keypresses, if the keypresses were post-processed in a manner similar to the stenotype.

Re:Twiddler 3 chording keyboard now available by kazinator on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @04:18PM (#8598247)
Is that 200 WPM counting expanded words or the raw steno notation? From the same Wikipedia page:

"Some court reporters use scopists to translate and edit their work. A scopist is a person who is trained in the phonetic writing system, English punctuation, and usually in legal formatting."

I.e. there is a post-processing pass whereby phonetic gibberish is translated into legible English with good spelling, grammar and punctuation.

Is the WPM calculation done on the raw input to the scopist, who expands it to proper English, or is it calculated over their output?

See, in ordinary English-language typing tests, you type full sentences. Mistakes in spelling and punctuation subtract from your WPM score.

Re:Twiddler 3 chording keyboard now available by bumbledraven on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @04:58PM (#8598519)
Is that 200 WPM counting expanded words or the raw steno notation?

It counts expanded words. In steno, the typist's chord (known as a "stroke") is a phonetic abbreviation that is automatically expanded into a word or phrase by software with a lookup table. Some steno software does slightly more complex expansion, but the vast majority of it is pure dictionary lookup.

in ordinary English-language typing tests, you type full sentences. Mistakes in spelling and punctuation subtract from your WPM score.

I see what you mean. It looks like WPM in steno is measured at sub-100% accuracy rates, whereas on a QWERTY keyboard it's measured at 100% accuracy. I'm not sure how to precisely compare steno speeds to QWERTY, but no QWERTY typist has ever come close to the speed of the fastest stenographers. For example, according to http://www.guinnessworldrecords.com/world-records/3000/faste..., "Mark Kislingbury of Houston, Texas, USA is the National Court Reporters Association speed and real-time champion, achieving 360 words per minute with 97.23% accuracy, at the NCRA 2004 summer convention on 30 July 2004."

Re:Twiddler 3 chording keyboard now available by dllthomas on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @03:40PM (#8597993)
One thing I played with is what I called a "partially chorded" keyboard, where chords in one section determine a mapping for the other. I used this to let me type on a midi piano keyboard (where the two sections were neighboring octaves), and it was surprisingly useable for the minimal experience I had with it. Of course, ease of use at the outset is only a poor proxy for capabilities in the long run...

I would note that it doesn't suffer nearly as much from the problem you describe, as changes of chorded position happen more rarely. It might well still have grown painful as I got faster, but it was interesting (and fun to be able to type on a piano keyboard - I've been wanting to rig up my organ to accept input that way).

Re:Twiddler 3 chording keyboard now available by mc_hammer on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @03:54PM (#8598080)
i think the point is to mash the word like a piano pushing CABD all at the same time, so instead of typing 30 letters to make a sentence you mash word1 word2 word3 word4 word5, similar to 5 keystrokes instead of 30... im looking forward to trying one myself