News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by JoshTriplett on Monday September 22, 2014 @02:16PM (#8351718)
"If I take a letter, lock it in a safe, hide the safe somewhere in New York, and then tell you to read the letter, that’s not security. That’s obscurity. On the other hand, if I take a letter and lock it in a safe, and then give you the safe along with the design specifications of the safe and a hundred identical safes with their combinations so that you and the world’s best safecrackers can study the locking mechanism — and you still can’t open the safe and read the letter, that’s security." -- Applied Cryptography, Bruce Schneier

If you distribute a program with broken security, it needs testing and fixing. If this was a real program, as opposed to an exercise, it would have gotten a security advisory.

So, the only failed "test" here would be writing a reverse-engineering-resistant program and expecting that to provide "security", and that's less a test of morals and more a test of competence. But as an exercise, written to be intentionally buggy, this was quite good.

Now, a good question to ask before this exercise would have been to ask the inverviewee to discuss the idea and implications of prompting for a password in a client-side application; look for them to explain public/private key cryptography and security versus obscurity.

Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by icelancer on Monday September 22, 2014 @01:59PM (#8351634)
> but trustworthy people do not walk around testing doorknobs to see if they are locked.

Yes, I agree. They do not go around testing doorknobs unsolicited and without permission. Which has absolutely nothing at all to do with this story, since he has both permission and was instructed to do so by his interviewers.

He was not asked to crack the NSA's database on metadata for phone calls. They are command line examples.

I downvoted you for unnecessarily swiping at the candidate saying: "This was a test of morals, and you flunked." You state this absolutely when in reality it is almost certainly a subjective minority opinion you hold.

Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by metacorrector on Monday September 22, 2014 @02:08PM (#8351673)
Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by forgottenpass on Monday September 22, 2014 @02:33PM (#8351808)
on the Gaussian Bell Curve of morality, as I pointed out myself about myself I lie at one end of the spectrum (two standard deviations above the mean, as I see it). Every population will have such a distribution. You are downvoting an outlyer because you disagree with him

I didn't care what your morals are, it's just bad interviewing. But, if you really want to bring up your morals, why are you deploying underhanded interview tactics? You let applications rest on the implied assumptions about a professional environment. Someone is extending you the professional courtesy of assuming that (if hired) you won't ask them to act immorally; you use that against them to walk them into a trap. How does that fit into your moral system?

Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by icelancer on Monday September 22, 2014 @02:10PM (#8351685)
I am downvoting you for unnecessarily swiping at the candidate by forcing your minority opinion on him. "This is a test of morals, and you failed" is a harsh judgment that only you and maybe a few other crusaders hold. Do not authoritatively state it and expect others to support you.

Don't make it look like you are being persecuted. You are the one lording over a minority opinion over someone in an attempt to persecute them.

Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by CocaKoala on Monday September 22, 2014 @02:46PM (#8351874)
Can you tell me what company you work for where you may be in a position to hire people? I'd like to make sure I never waste my time by applying there.
Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by nerdy on Monday September 22, 2014 @02:00PM (#8351648)
I firmly disagree...

They didn't ask him to crack Photoshop or AutoCAD or anything... they're freaking crackmes. It seems like quite a sensible way to approach such an interview since it takes significant time, can be done overnight on their own workstation and isn't a huge requirement like "write us a game entirely in assembly".

There is nothing immoral about cracking a crackme file, which is the very reason why the file was created.

Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by metacorrector on Monday September 22, 2014 @02:14PM (#8351707)
Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by forgottenpass on Monday September 22, 2014 @02:10PM (#8351687)
I don't think you're wrong, The interview tactic is not useful for testing morals, your interview is testing the interviewee's aptitude for identifying underhanded questions (and/or their ability to sidestep a pointed questioning on a skill they're weak at).

But if somebody says "we want to hire you, pick this lock", your first response has simply got to be "wait, we need to discuss this."

Is the lock attached to your competitor's back door, or did you just place a lock cylinder on the meeting table? Remember, you're hiring a locksmith.

You've provided the applicant an ethical and legally safe environment to apply their skillset and tasked them with proving their skillset. What do you expect to happen?

How many of your everyday business skills can be used immorally? If you preface every demonstration or application of your abilities with a moral clarification, my immediate thought would be "The lady doth protest too much, methinks"

Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by goshx on Monday September 22, 2014 @02:00PM (#8351646)
When I find myself in the role of employer again, which could be soon, I'm going to use this to test potential employees. The people I hire will say "I know how to use a debugger to reverse engineer machine code, but I don't crack passwords" or some variation of that.

There is a good chance you would hire someone that doesn't know how to do it. If you don't want them to do it, then don't ask. This, IMO, is the wrong way to test morals.

I don't see anything immoral about it. It was not a real application, it was not causing damage to anyone and it was totally related to the job position.

Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by forgottenpass on Monday September 22, 2014 @03:11PM (#8352015)
But I do think this is a serious issue and I'm astonished at the sheer number of you who cannot allow discussion of it and will not allow your beliefs to be questioned.

We _were_ discussing it, you got a few downvotes, so what? Disagreement is a form of discussion, had you wished to iterate on the explanation of your stance I would have gladly continued until we distilled the conversation down to the core bits we don't see eye to eye on. Maybe neither of us would be swayed, but at least we'd see where one another were coming from.

I said this before but deleted it because I thought it was a low blow, but in light of your edit I'll reiterate: the problem with this conversation was not your moral stance, it was your arrogance.

Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by scott_s on Monday September 22, 2014 @02:34PM (#8351819)
You're being downvoted because your comment is, to most of us, a complete non-sequitur. Everyone understands that "cracking" this program is a harmless game. Successfully doing so, however, demonstrates that the interviewee has a decent grasp of various systems concepts, and is able to apply them.
Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by genofon on Monday September 22, 2014 @01:58PM (#8351630)
you do realize that he was not cracking a normal program but one made to be cracked right?
Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by metacorrector on Monday September 22, 2014 @02:26PM (#8351768)
Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by mattmanser on Monday September 22, 2014 @01:53PM (#8351606)
I have no idea why you think a security researcher shouldn't know how virtual locks work and be able to penetrate them, in my mind it seems a reasonable skill test, and so why you think this is immoral is completely beyond me.

Would you have the same objections if the test was a complicated SQL injection?

Re:I was asked to crack a program in a job interview, part 2 by metacorrector on Monday September 22, 2014 @02:29PM (#8351781)