> Deresiewicz left Yale after failing to get tenure; he now lives in Portland, Oregon, and writes.

EDIT: parent's post is deleted by was something along the lines of "well now it seems to be even more of a breakup piece"

Yes, and now your argument sounds like it's just trying to find reasons to criticize Deresiewicz. He left? Well then this is a breakup piece! He's still there? Then he's a hypocrite!