News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by tokenizer on Thursday January 09, 2014 @03:08PM (#7032834)
Hate to go against my gold bug brothers, but no monetary supply requires a physical backing; just confidence.

Yes backing a currency in gold will give confidence. Yes backing a fractional reserve with a military and resources will give confidence.

If bitcoin can TRULY deliver on its promises as a payment transmitter, than it may just get enough confidence to become a currency as well.

As it stands now however, it looks like a speculative commodity.

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by brc on Thursday January 09, 2014 @10:42PM (#7034974)
The difference is that nothing can remove the confidence behind gold - not even forced confiscation by the state (which just results in hoarding and buried treasure).

However, it's easy, simple to undermine confidence in fiat currency - just overissue and prevent conversion to other forms.

Can confidence in Bitcoin be removed? Not sure about that one. Would banning trade in it like gold can be banned remove all confidence? Very hard to say, and something to watch.

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by tokenizer on Friday January 10, 2014 @09:09AM (#7036591)
You make good points. I agree with your point on gold. I was just highlighting the fact that confidence is what is key, and people are not 100% rationale, which can lead to weird confidence, whether that means no confidence for a good system, or good confidence.
Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by thekaleb on Thursday January 09, 2014 @03:18PM (#7032895)
Like gold, BTC has scarcity, but unlike gold, it has no intrinsic value. I do, however, value my Bitcoins.
Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by blhack on Thursday January 09, 2014 @03:32PM (#7032989)
People constantly talk about the industrial applications of gold.

If we end up in a place where world governments have fallen to the point where we no longer trust their money, and have switched back to gold, what industry is going to still be around using gold?

I just don't see this.

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by dragonwriter on Thursday January 09, 2014 @03:40PM (#7033066)
There's no currency backed by all world governments collectively, just currencies backed by particular world governments (usually individually, though the Euro is backed by a particular group). It's quite easy to imagine a failure of monetary policy by any one (or more relevantly, any two) of those central banks that would leave gold using industries in existence in the world, and gold in a better position than the relevant fiat currencies.

If there were a single global universal fiat currency, that might not be the case, but ethereal isn't one.

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by tokenizer on Thursday January 09, 2014 @04:21PM (#7033349)
> If there were a single global universal fiat currency, that might not be the case, but ethereal isn't one.

I think we may see this if bitcoin becomes too popular. I mean, it may be too late by then, but why not try right? Oppressors gotta oppress.

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by Sambdala on Thursday January 09, 2014 @04:00PM (#7033197)
Leaving aside the issues of whether or not there is such a thing as intrinsic value (I would argue there isn't), any industrial/jewelry/etc uses of Gold would put a floor on it's price of something in the low double digits per ounce, if that.

This just means for Gold, you effectively have a Put option for a very small percentage of what it's currently trading at, instead of 0% of what it's trading at.

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by tmountain on Thursday January 09, 2014 @03:27PM (#7032958)
BTC the currency may have no intrinsic value, but the bitcoin network has tremendous value as a means for frictionless transactions across borders.
Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by tokenizer on Thursday January 09, 2014 @04:19PM (#7033333)
I think some fans of gold don't see the benefits of the network (and network effect) of bitcoin.

That said, if it becomes too much of a liability to store (hackers, taxes, transmission) in the future without the growth, then it'll lose confidence. I feel like any problems with security though would only become a reality when it would hit mass appeal.

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by kaonashi on Thursday January 09, 2014 @03:07PM (#7032829)
The more people rely on Bitcoin, the more volatile the economic activity surrounding it will be. It's not a 'failure' any more than a gold standard was a 'failure', but it's also suboptimal.
Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by dantheman on Thursday January 09, 2014 @03:09PM (#7032840)
As more people use it the less volatile it will be.
Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by nhaehnle on Thursday January 09, 2014 @03:19PM (#7032903)
In terms of exchange rate, Bitcoin will become less volatile, yes.

I suspect that kaonashi was referring to something else: there are macroeconomic problems associated with a gold standard, such as its tendency to push countries into recessionary spirals, which are also to be expected if Bitcoin (or a Bitcoin-standard) were used as the "normal" currency.

Note that this is not a problem as long as Bitcoin is only used as an intermediary during payment, where the majority use is $currency -> BTC -> $currency within a short time window, and where contracts are not denominated in BTC.

However, an economy in which BTC is used as the major unit of account is liable to the same problems as we historically observed with the gold standard.

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by ogreyonder on Thursday January 09, 2014 @03:48PM (#7033110)
After trying several times to write this reply without sounding snarky, because I am actually being sincere: can you link me to reading on historical problems directly caused by the gold standard? Or maybe some search terms?

I've heard this assertion a lot in regards to bitcoin/deflation. However, everything I can find winds up in the same place. The gold standard was fine, but countries abandoned it so they could print endless money to fund World War I.

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by brc on Thursday January 09, 2014 @10:51PM (#7035003)
No, you've got it right.

War is the mother of all inflation. Always has and always will be.

Rulers and governments of all stripes don't like having their spending ways crimped, so that's why it's no longer around.

You will read a lot of 'deflation madness' type articles, but deflation is merely the other side of inflation. There are winners and there are losers. There is no record of a country falling into a destructive deflationary spiral (really, can anything get destroyed by lower prices?), but there is a long laundry list of countries and empires destroyed by inflation, starting with the roman empire and currently displayed by Zimbabwe.

Some people will say a stronger currency (as compared with other currencies) is a good thing. Some people will say a weaker curency is a good thing. Neither is right. Inflation and Deflation are the same - both have effects - both create winners and losers. Most people have been taught to think that deflation = horror and inflation = roses. That's not surprising, given the government sets the curriculum and gains the most from persistent inflation.

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by gnaritas on Thursday January 09, 2014 @07:08PM (#7034155)
Just think about it a bit, fixed or barely growing supply of currency; what happens when the economy booms and the population grows, more demand for that money, no more supply of that money, the value of the money must go up, goods must be marked down in price, salaries must be lowered, because there's less money being used by more people.

Deflation; it strangles an economy for obvious reasons that require nothing more than understanding the inevitable consequences of fixing the supply of your medium of exchange. Printing money is what keeps prices stable as the population and economy grows. If you didn't print more money, you'd be forced into deflation; you think people like their salaries being cut? Do vendors like lowering prices across the board not because things are cheaper, but because the value of money has risen? How do make long term contracts when the value of your money isn't stable? How do you get a 30 year mortgage or rent a place when no one knows what the currency will be worth tomorrow? That's why gold failed.

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by brc on Thursday January 09, 2014 @10:57PM (#7035024)
Well, no.

Inflation; it strangles an economy for obvious reasons that require nothing more than understanding the inevitable consequences of endless increasing the supply of your medium of exchange. Printing money is what keeps prices rising forever as the population and economy grows. If you endlessly print more money, you'd be forced into inflation; you think people like the value of their labor constantly reduced? Do vendors like rising prices across the board not because things are more expensive to produce, but because the value of money has fallen? How do make long term contracts when the value of your money isn't stable? How do you get a 30 year mortgage or rent a place when no one knows what the currency will be worth tomorrow? That's why fiat currencies always fail.

Inflation/Deflation are both effects - the difference is that it is impossible to reduce the prices of things to zero, but it is possible [and has been done, many times] to increase prices to infinity.

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by gnaritas on Friday January 10, 2014 @01:25AM (#7035386)
Yes, they're both not ideal, but they aren't equal in badness. What's better, 1% inflation or 1% deflation, because 0 isn't possible. I suspect we can part ways with the answer to that question.
Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by ogreyonder on Friday January 10, 2014 @11:20AM (#7037361)
While I appreciate the effort that went into writing this thought experiment, that's not what I'm interested in.

I would like a historical example demonstrating the problem of the gold standard. The world worked this way for centuries, so surely there must be some documented case of one of the doom scenarios you proposed.

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by gnaritas on Friday January 10, 2014 @04:47PM (#7039724)
One need only look at the occurrences of and severity of the markets boom bust cycle before and after the we left the gold standard. We've had no depressions since the great depression and the recessions since then have been far milder than the many depressions/recessions before then. Depressions were a common occurrence under the gold standard, we've had none since we went off it. This doesn't prove causation, but given the role of deflation[1] in many of those recessions/depressions, it's certainly correlated.

The world didn't abandon the gold standard because it was working; they abandoned it because gold is a poor currency that suffered from deflation. Bitcoin will have the same problems, but may succeed anyway because it can't and won't replace the dollar, but will serve as digital gold; it's a good commodity but a poor currency. No one sane will be pricing anything in Bitcoin, they'll spot price in Bitcoin based on the current USD exchange rate.

I'm a Bitcoin supporter, but that doesn't mean I have to ignore history.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_recessions_in_the_Unite...

Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by kaonashi on Thursday January 09, 2014 @04:07PM (#7033242)
The main problem with the gold standard is that the amount of gold becomes a real constraint on production, even though gold is not actually used in production.
Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by seiji on Thursday January 09, 2014 @04:08PM (#7033250)
Doesn't one wallet control something like 40% of all issuance so far? Sure, that's completely stable.
Re:Overstock.com Is Now Accepting Bitcoins by gigq on Thursday January 09, 2014 @07:09PM (#7034159)