News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by mtgx on Sunday June 30, 2013 @01:46PM (#5966494)
Besides, I don't care how "legal" they make it or how much oversight and checks they put in place.

At the end of the day, they're still collecting everything. And I don't want that to happen. Is that too much to ask for? Google got in so much trouble over collecting Wi-fi data, but if the governments do it, and a lot more, it's fine? Surely there have been, and will continue to be alternative solutions to stopping terrorists besides collecting everyone's information en-masse.

Also, what about the foreigners? Politicians, judges, activists, everyone is fair game for spying? I don't want to live in such a world. That's can't be the future.

Obama tries to make it seem like this is the "balance" between privacy and security. This nowhere close to a "balance". They're getting everything. How is that a "balance" for privacy? If that's the balance, I don't think I want to know what they have in mind for when they really only care about security.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by Sven7 on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:24PM (#5966643)
Have you forgotten yes we can...this is the guy, a professor of constitutional law at Harvard no less, that accepted the peace prize, while running two wars and with a 'kill list' in his pocket, so don't worry Obama can balance anything.

I hope they give him another Nobel for just being so awesome.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by B0Z on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:20PM (#5966828)
They look like bigger fools now for giving him the Nobel than they did when he hadn't accomplished anything.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by ihsw on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:30PM (#5966868)
The 'Nobel' as you put it encompasses multiple fields, most of which are based in sciences proven by empirical analysis. The 'Peace' prize has historically been controversial as contributions to peace are inherently political in nature.

Please don't disregard the other prizes: they represent real, quantifiable achievements. Peace is a simple result from political policies, but chemistry, physics, and medicine have a rich history of research and application.

Nobel Prize categories:

* Physics

* Chemistry

* Literature

* Peace

* Physiology

* Medicine

* Economic Sciences

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by rdl on Sunday June 30, 2013 @04:40PM (#5967103)
The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel is actually distinct from the "real" Nobels. It is also even more of a joke than the Peace Prize, often.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by ihsw on Sunday June 30, 2013 @05:05PM (#5967201)
I would rather not argue about 'economic sciences' at this time, that subject is usually far more politicized than 'peace.'
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by rplacd on Sunday June 30, 2013 @05:34PM (#5967316)
The Prize in Literature's never free of the usual political recriminations either - there's a fine line between endorsing a message and acknowledging execution (and the fact that the ends an author sets plays an important role as well) that's never been fully articulated.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by pfortuny on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:31PM (#5966667)
There is always the Nobel of Literature... Do not despair. They are really putting a lot of effort into it.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by mzs on Sunday June 30, 2013 @09:19PM (#5968097)
UofC not Harvard
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by jaekwon on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:26PM (#5966848)
The grand "balance" has been under our nose the entire time, as laid out by prof Lessig, also of Harvard.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5964883

I think it is ignorance that is causing this. Specifically, ignorance of the nature of information, and maybe a propensity of lawyers to attempt to "balance" security with law, and thereby destroy security.

Read my other comment here about Palantir's marketing material, how they advertise "immutable audit trails", and how that's supposed to provide transparency and whatever... and a link to a paper that says it doesn't work. Of course it doesn't work.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5965317

I don't blog, so somebody else should compile this and publish it.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by munin on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:26PM (#5966652)
> And I don't want that to happen. Is that too much to ask for?

civilization and government are way more nuanced than this. the answer to your question is yes, yes it is too much to ask for. you probably don't want to pay taxes, receive speeding tickets, or be subject to laws but you are...

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by andy_ppp on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:29PM (#5966864)
I always find it funny that taxes are only for the poor as far as I'm aware. In reality speeding tickets aren't for reckless driving they are for funding police departments. The laws we have are and have always been designed to require whole teams of specialised people at great expense to debate whether, in fact you are or aren't in contradiction of them (insert campaign for plain terms legal messaging that is binding). In fact the law is so complex now that if you can pay for the smartest people to get you off the hook on technicalities.

We didn't get onto corporate power and influence in this thread (yet) but you get the idea. Is shut up and take it an option anymore when it's looking increasingly likely that governments corrupt and subvert real public debate (infiltrating organisations like Greenpeace with trouble makers), monitor everything you do on the internet and can trace it all back to you, and should the policies change under, say a Nixon, McCarthy or worse you could find the apparatus on your doorstep for a making everyone a suspected terrorist fairly soon. Turnkey Tyranny is exactly the correct terminology.

The truth is you can't trust the NSA to do the right thing and anyone with any common sense can see even in very very recent American history the powers of the state were massively abused. Freedom, democracy, these always have just been words to sugar coats a system by the rich for the rich. I the more you look at the system the more you realise that Chomsky is right about power and that you and me all need a fairer slice of the cake (both monetarily and in terms of our say in how government happens). What is good is that the means of production is coming back to the people; I can see the rich and powerful being very scared indeed by this.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by jaekwon on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:50PM (#5966932)
How are the means of production coming back to the people? I'd like to know, because that's where the hope is.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by andy_ppp on Sunday June 30, 2013 @06:03PM (#5967428)
Within 20 years 3d printing and Open Ecology will have given _you_ the means to pretty much never need to buy anything from the man again. Real communities that live off the grid can happen within our life times (and it not be the most tiresome back breaking work in the world) and maybe we can find a bit of happiness in the joy of being human rather than the endless procession of churning out ever more so that the rich above us can steal it from us.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by embolism on Sunday June 30, 2013 @08:59PM (#5968042)
How will people in those communities pay their taxes?
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by jaekwon on Sunday June 30, 2013 @10:55PM (#5968371)
Presumably through voluntary subscription to private services, or flat taxation of alternative currencies controlled by and tied to local communities where usage of the currency is voluntary.

The way we're taxed federally right now with corporate loopholes and crazy income tax laws is bad.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by embolism on Sunday June 30, 2013 @11:42PM (#5968493)
The people who operate the current tax system probably won't take kindly to an alternative system just being 'declared'. And they have lots of guns.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by andy_ppp on Monday July 01, 2013 @09:46AM (#5970542)
Why would these communities need money? On what basis would they be taxed with no income?
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by embolism on Monday July 01, 2013 @01:15PM (#5972055)
Tax is assessed on exchanges of value - not money itself.

Otherwise, corporations would be able to just pay people in kind by providing them with accommodation, transport, clothing, etc, and save a giant tax bill.

If a significant sized community creates a moneyless economy, the tax man authorities will take an interest, and just start assessing transactions based on financial equivalences.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by jaekwon on Monday July 01, 2013 @06:27PM (#5974020)
Yes, and I hope you do see that taxing this self-sufficient community (assuming it did not require the benefits from the govt like highways and whatnot) would be akin to theft if it were compulsory.

Of course all communities require something from the global external economy, but I see no reason why a community's internal transactions would have to be assessed by an external entity. Alas that is not the way of the world today.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by embolism on Tuesday July 02, 2013 @12:14PM (#5978811)
I agree with you about the ethics of this. I'm just pointing out that the technology for self sufficiency isn't the major barrier. It's the politics that are the problem.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by solnyshok on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:21PM (#5966834)
2013.06.30 Your monthly privacy balance calculated by NSA: ZERO.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by e3pi on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:30PM (#5966663)
This condescending mollifying paternal tone is a case study of an arrogant recklessly dangerous fool equating the vast resources he directs as equivalent to his own intelligence and competence. An intelligent reflective director would be humbled and pained by this awful responsibility, contrast Alexander with leader models we do respect: iconic Dwight Eisenhower, Abe Lincoln, or General George Washington.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by throwaway9848 on Sunday June 30, 2013 @01:35PM (#5966455)
Well, the beauty of a democratic society is that if a majority agree with you, then you can change the system. Personally, I disagree with you, but it's a free country.

Your comment about the military is so rude, though, that it was difficult to write a temperate response. You ought to feel ashamed of yourself.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by csallen on Sunday June 30, 2013 @01:40PM (#5966479)
There's certainly nothing rude about pointing out a relevant and possibly non-obvious truth: military life is so distinct from civilian life that it may result in drastically different perspectives about what it means to be free. If merely being exposed to a hypothesis you disagree with offends you, then I don't understand how you can ever hope to have a meaningful debate.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by jivatmanx on Sunday June 30, 2013 @01:58PM (#5966550)
Moreover, this isn't a new idea, it led to the opposition many founding fathers had to "Standing Armies".

Soldiers are, in a sense, slaves. A standing army is a vast apparatus under direct control of an executive.

But, the opposition to standing armies is long forgotten. We also forgot the reason why only congress was given the authority to declare war, which has become dead letter, and these ideas considered quaint and outdated. But 1776 wasn't that long ago in the history of human governments, and the history of human governments is the history of abusing power.

"Not to know what happened before you were born is to be a child forever." - Cicero

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by mpyne on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:45PM (#5966706)
> Soldiers are, in a sense, slaves. A standing army is a vast apparatus under direct control of an executive.

The U.S. military's only oath is to the Constitution of the U.S., not the executive. They are to follow the orders of the executive to the point that they are in keeping with upholding the defense of the nation against all enemies, foreign and domestic.

Officers don't even take an oath to zealously follow orders, only to properly discharge the duties of their position.

While I'll grant that it's true that there is a lot of leeway and deference to the executive branch in what counts as a 'lawful order', it's incredibly concerning to me that so many people here have so little understanding of the U.S. military that they can claim with a straight face that the standing army is Obama's personal political tool.

Please see http://terminallance.com/2013/05/17/terminal-lance-president... for a description of how little reverence there is for the President within the military.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by oz on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:38PM (#5966894)
This is true in theory, but soldiers the world over a trained simply to follow orders without question. How many soldiers when given an order, stop and think to debate the Constitutional issues, if any?

Mind you, there are good reasons for training soldiers this way - In the heat of combat, the Platoon Commander can't put everything to a vote. But this way of life does have its negatives.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by rdl on Sunday June 30, 2013 @04:43PM (#5967113)
Generally, in the US military, officers (which include virtually all pilots) and senior enlisted actually do take into account legal (constitutional, other laws, and rules of engagement) concerns in making decisions. Even in combat, decisions about what weapons can be used do have legal input (i.e. can we blow up a mosque? What if it's actively being used to fire on us? Or what if it just has a spotter in it relaying fire missions to a mortar team elsewhere in a crowded village square?).

Junior enlisted, yes, generally just follow orders from their immediate superiors.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by getpost on Sunday June 30, 2013 @05:34PM (#5967317)
Speaking of oaths, the President's oath is to "preserve, protect and defend the Constitution," not to protect the health or safety of Americans in general. Do NSA officials take an oath like the President's?

Every NSA employee knows they're violating the constitution. Keith Alexander's statement in an embarrassment, which only calls attention to the corruption or ignorance at the top.

Edit: spelling

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by throwaway9848 on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:18PM (#5966618)
"Soldiers are, in a sense, slaves"

Except that in the US, military service is voluntary.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by anon1385 on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:41PM (#5966698)
http://usmilitary.about.com/od/punitivearticles/a/mcm85.htm

(1) Completed or attempted desertion with intent to avoid hazardous duty or to shirk important service. Dishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and confinement for 5 years.

(2) Other cases of completed or attempted desertion.

(a) Terminated by apprehension. Dishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and confinement for 3 years.

(b) Terminated otherwise. Dishonorable discharge, forfeiture of all pay and allowances, and confinement for 2 years.

(3) In time of war. Death or such other punishment as a court-martial may direct.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by mpyne on Sunday June 30, 2013 @05:51PM (#5967382)
Yes. That applies after you have volunteered to be bound by it in the current military.

The draft register is still around but the draft itself was eliminated in 1973 (or thereabouts). So, that U.S. military force propping up NATO and facing down the U.S.S.R. during Reagan's saber-rattling in the 1980s? ALL VOLUNTEER, believe it or not.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by jivatmanx on Sunday June 30, 2013 @06:38PM (#5967547)
Also interesting is that Milton Friedman considered his role in ending the draft his proudest achievement.

Friedman had no qualms about describing himself as a libertarian and not a conservative, and his influence in the Reagan administration was considerable, even outside of economics.

I find it strange that so many conservatives admire Reagan as their ultimate hero, but ignore any libertarian influence in his administration.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by throwaway2048 on Sunday June 30, 2013 @06:40PM (#5967555)
You could (and still can) voluntarily sell yourself into slavery, it's still slavery.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by mpyne on Sunday June 30, 2013 @07:59PM (#5967867)
It's surprisingly easy to get back out of the military, if you really want to. You just have to be willing to deal with a general or other-than-honorable discharge.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by learc83 on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:33PM (#5966672)
Indentured servant is probably a better term to describe what the OP was intending. They agree to enter into a period of service, during which they give up control of most aspects of their lives that civilians take for granted, e.g., they face jail time if they leave.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by jivatmanx on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:34PM (#5966675)
Slavery could, historically, be entered into voluntarily. John Stuart Mill wrote some interesting things about this.

But clearly, this isn't the basis of my comparison. A soldier is completely subject to the arbitrary will of his superiors, without any real legal protections.

See also: Ratio of reported rapes vs. prosecuted rapes, scandals of enforcement agents.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by sweettea on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:34PM (#5966676)
Except that WWII and the Vietnam War both involved mandatory drafts in the US, and as a result, almost all US citizens of our age are barely two generations descended from a veteran of the US military. Even if your father didn't serve, your father's father probably did, taught him with a perspective colored by having been a slave in the military, and he likely raised you with a perspective colored thereby also.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by pvdm on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:56PM (#5966748)
Heard of wage slavery ?
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by mpyne on Sunday June 30, 2013 @05:54PM (#5967398)
Recruiting standards have been too high since 2007 actually. You're actually more likely to get in the military as a descendant of a middle-class family than from a poor family. And if you exclude the Army, that has been true since 2001 or so.

And post-2009 when active operations in Iraq were ending and the economy really went to shit it's gotten even harder to join. You essentially can't even get into the various Officer Candidate Schools without being either in peak physical shape (Army/Marines) and having good grades, or having a GPA of 3.4+ with good physical scores (Navy/Air Force).

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by hobs on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:34PM (#5966678)
Correct, but that is why it is in a sense. I think if you expand this thought it is similar to how many people buy into their own company's bullshit while you stand on the outside and just shake your head.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by sage_joch on Sunday June 30, 2013 @01:54PM (#5966532)
Well, the beauty of a democratic society is that if a majority agree with you, then you can change the system.

This is technically true, but ignores the fact that it's a totally rigged game. You have a news media that's intent on dividing people over relatively small issues and pushing certain narratives. You have contractors who are paid to do the same online. You have a system of surveillance that could be used to discredit (or worse) promising political figures, and intimidate journalists. You have a large part of your government that operates in secret, under secret laws, preventing any kind of meaningful debate beyond "we need more transparency." All of this makes it incredibly difficult to get a majority to agree with anything that established powers don't approve of. It can be done (like we're seeing with marijuana legalization), but it requires a Herculean effort.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by unoti on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:11PM (#5966797)
People who disagree with this comment and say it's false would do well to read this book http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0104810/ Manufacturing Consent, by Noam Chomsky. It is very well researched, carefully documented. At least look at the information and think about it. The people don't have nearly as much control as it seems.

"It is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it." - Aristotle

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by rayiner on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:01PM (#5966762)
This is such arrogant bullshit. You're basically saying that if only everyone else were as enlightened as you, they'd care about the objectively important issues like NSA spying, instead of "relatively small issues" like abortion or gay rights, etc. Among my group of friends, DOMA generated far more interest than the NSA news. Are they just misled by the media?

What utter self aggrandizing tripe.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by sage_joch on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:43PM (#5966905)
Among my group of friends, DOMA generated far more interest than the NSA news. Are they just misled by the media?

I wouldn't blame anyone for taking more interest in gay rights than the NSA. The emerging widespread acceptance of gays as fellow human beings is probably unique to human history. It is hard to overstate the significance of that. But at the same time, I wouldn't give too much credit to the news media. It was a convenient wedge issue, but I suspect established powers were largely indifferent as to the outcome.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by rayiner on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:51PM (#5966939)
Among my friends, gay rights, abortion, the environment, wrongful convictions (of poor black kids in the inner city, not "patriots" like Snowden), taxes, social security, and healthcare all outrank "privacy" in terms of importance. Are they just brainwashed into this by the "established powers"?
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by sage_joch on Sunday June 30, 2013 @04:26PM (#5967054)
Brainwashed is a strong word, and I've never met your friends. But I would argue that the NSA story is vastly more important than the issues you mentioned, except possibly the environment (and see my comment above about gay rights). My reasoning has more to do with the potential for abuse than the abuse that has already come to light. I think it is best summed up by this NY Times excerpt on Frank Church, the first senator to investigate the NSA:

He added that if a dictator ever took over, the N.S.A. "could enable it to impose total tyranny, and there would be no way to fight back."

http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/25/weekinreview/25bamford.htm...

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by rayiner on Sunday June 30, 2013 @04:35PM (#5967084)
You think the NSA story is "vastly more important" based on your calculus of how it might be abused and how likely it is to be abused. Don't you think people are entitled to come to differing conclusions about that without accusations that they are brainwashed by the media? Because that's basically what you're doing when you reject the impact of the democratic process in all this: people can't be trusted to hold their own opinions because they're guided to opinions by the media.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by tomrod on Sunday June 30, 2013 @07:00PM (#5967639)
This is not a moral gray area. The NSA is the government breaking its laws, throwing off its checks, and establishing tyranny. The other issues that have been brought up in this thread (gay rights, abortion) are pittances as a people we humbly request of the government.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by rayiner on Sunday June 30, 2013 @10:57PM (#5968379)
Or, the NSA program is a targeted intelligence system designed to stay within the wide latitude afforded by the law and the 4th amendment? Not the establishment of tyranny, but a mundane apparatus that ultimately will have little real impact on the lives of ordinary Americans.

I think reasonable minds can differ about which characterization is appropriate.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by tomrod on Monday July 01, 2013 @11:58AM (#5971468)
Granted. However, the actions of the however-characterized NSA is where there is little moral gray area.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by jacquesm on Sunday June 30, 2013 @04:30PM (#5967065)
Someone who sacrifices everything he's got, exposes a bunch of bad things his government is doing at great personal risk to himself has definitely earned the patriot label, Snowden is doing a lot more to improve America than most of the flag waving bumper sticker crowd that happily affix that label onto themselves.

Taxes, social security and healthcare are important, but they are not more or less important than privacy on an absolute scale and they are not on the same axis to begin with. You can have a perfect police state with social security, healthcare and low taxes and 0 privacy.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by thenewkid on Sunday June 30, 2013 @04:07PM (#5966991)
Perhaps your friends are not able to prioritise?

Privacy is a fundamental human right recognized in the UN Declaration of Human Rights.

What good is it to have the right to abortion, gay marriage, immigration amnesty etc. if tomorrow you can be taken away and locked up for the rest of your life, without any due process, all because of an email you wrote?

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by rayiner on Sunday June 30, 2013 @04:18PM (#5967035)
The UN Declaration of Human Rights is not law in the United States and recognizes many things that are not recognized as fundamental rights in the United States: right to international travel, right to social security, right to "desirable work" and to join trade unions, right to "rest and leisure", right to education, etc.

Also, your hypothetical is disingenuous. It wraps violations of due process in with monitoring of e-mail. I'd imagine most people would consider the real outrage in your hypothetical to be the "without any due process" part, not the "because of an e-mail" part.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by UVB-76 on Sunday June 30, 2013 @01:46PM (#5966495)
> Well, the beauty of a democratic society is that if a majority agree with you, then you can change the system. Personally, I disagree with you, but it's a free country.

The majority are disengaged, disinterested and apathetic.

Furthermore, the particularly abhorrent feature of these programs is that their existence was kept secret. Secret courts issuing secret orders to secret services to work in secret violating citizens' right to privacy.

Without these leaks, citizens lacked the capacity to change this system, because they had no idea this system even existed.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by straight_talk on Sunday June 30, 2013 @09:31PM (#5968129)
Excellent arguments.

Total surveillance is one of the many tools, that the political elite uses to prevent the majority from changing the system.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by ferdo on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:33PM (#5966876)
> the beauty of a democratic society is that if a majority agree with you, then you can change the system.

This is false. The NSA considers itself outside the realm of law:

> "NSA does not have a statutory charter; its operational responsibilities are set forth exclusively in executive directives first issued in the 1950s. One of the questions which the Senate asked the Committee to consider was the "need for specific legislative authority to govern the operations of...the National Security Agency."

> According to NSA's General Counsel, no existing statutes control, limit, or define the signals intelligence activities of NSA. Further, the General Counsel asserts that the Fourth Amendment does not apply to NSA's interception of Americans' international communications for foreign intelligence purposes."

> http://www.aarclibrary.org/publib/church/reports/book3/pdf/C...

We'd have to overthrow the "government" as it's existed for the past 50 years or so to get rid of the NSA.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by btipling on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:27PM (#5966851)
I served in the military. I have nothing but respect and admiration for our service members and their sacrifice. But when it comes to liberty, a military life isn't one filled with it. I don't see what is rude about making this statement. Obviously this officer doesn't understand the meaning of the word, at least now how I understand it.

I admit I regret my phrasing. Instead of "but it is not surprising that officers in the military do not understand what liberty means since they have not lived a life of liberty" I should have said "but it is not surprising that an officer in the military may not understand what liberty means since they have not lived a life of liberty"

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by throwaway9848 on Monday July 01, 2013 @12:41AM (#5968686)
I regret phrasing my response that strongly. I still disagree, but I see where you're coming from. Thank you for your service.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by nhangen on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:52PM (#5966732)
In the upper ranks of the officer class, this is certainly true. I met many LT's and Captains that I enjoyed working with, but once they reached beyond those early grades, they became part of the officer's elite/gentleman's club, where they became further detached from their subordinates and more interested in appealing to their masters.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by alistair77 on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:03PM (#5966566)
That's only true if the voters have visibility of what they're voting for. That's wht is so bad about this situation, the secracy negates the foundation of democracy
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by ISL on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:04PM (#5966578)
The military comment strikes me as uninformed. Military officers [1] I know tend to be above average in understanding our rights, liberties, freedoms, and responsibilities.

[1] Edit: And enlisted men and women!

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by blueprint on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:05PM (#5966581)
Am I dreaming? The USA is not a democratic society. The will of the people is not only unrepresented in the government, but the legal means by which the will of the people would be imposed are totally dismantled. Furthermore, it's not a free country by a long shot. Do you know anyone that does not have to live relying on centrally distributed energy and food?
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by LoganCale on Sunday June 30, 2013 @08:09PM (#5967904)
I know people who are fully on solar/wind power and grow their own food.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by blueprint on Sunday June 30, 2013 @09:26PM (#5968115)
Solar/wind account for a fraction of US energy usage, and such people are unfortunately the extreme exception.

It's almost impossible for a human alive today to truthfully live free from oil - even if they are exceptional. How much harder would it be for an ordinary person who actually lives in US society?

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by mattmanser on Sunday June 30, 2013 @01:48PM (#5966507)
That's mob rule you're describing, not democracy. And mobs love trampling over the freedoms of minorities.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by throwaway9848 on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:15PM (#5966606)
What a lovely sound-bite.

What was it, aside from "mob rule" of the majority, that passed amendments 14, 15, 19, 24, and 26 to the Constitution? Those would be the amendments that specifically expanded the freedoms of minorities (on the basic of race, sex, wealth, and age)

EDIT: oh, and I mean the supermajority & state level process required to amend the Constitution.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by mattmanser on Sunday June 30, 2013 @04:07PM (#5966990)
A lot of pain, blood, terror, injustice, tenacity and bravery as far as I understand it.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by leoc on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:23PM (#5966841)
> Well, the beauty of a democratic society is that if a majority agree with you, then you can change the system.

That may be a reasonable response to the PRISM/FAA702 disclosures. But in relation to the blanket domestic phone-metadata surveillance? The program which was based on an very expansive interpretation of the FAA business-records provision? The program which was kept secret from not only the US electorate but most of the US Congress? As was the legal interpretation justifying it? The program which even the US Congressmen who had heard about it and found it objectionable were not permitted to inform anyone about? http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=HNm...

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by vixen99 on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:26PM (#5966649)
I would have thought that going on a catch-all-you-can fishing expedition with the world as your pool is pretty rude as well.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by smtddr on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:06PM (#5966584)
> Your comment about the military is so rude, though, that it was difficult to write a temperate response. You ought to feel ashamed of yourself.

Sadly, I suspect one day you'll have to recall this statement.

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by ambassador451 on Sunday June 30, 2013 @01:59PM (#5966554)
You're right. Soldiers are ignorant sheeple unlike us here on reddit and HN who actually understand things.

It would be much better to have someone from reddit or HN in charge of the NSA. It could be decided by upvotes. Does anyone want to start a poll?

Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by straight_talk on Sunday June 30, 2013 @02:35PM (#5966679)
No, you're right. It's so much better to have old, ugly military guys take all the important decision, spy on, detain and torture people they don't like, without any courts. This is why North Korea is the engine of the world progress.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by embolism on Sunday June 30, 2013 @03:48PM (#5966921)
China is arguably the current engine of world progress, and there, state surveillance is ubiquitous and lawful, and a policeman can send you to jail without trial.
Re:Keith Alexander's Statement to the NSA Workforce by straight_talk on Sunday June 30, 2013 @09:16PM (#5968087)
Of course it is, if for some weird reason you think that assembly = R&D ...