News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:Back of the Envelope Calculations [pdf] by leoedin on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:56PM (#5519400)
I disagree. Being able to quickly understand what kind of range something will be in is a very important skill. I've met far too many engineers and engineering students who have no real concept of magnitude. In an academic setting, that can lead to comically large or small answers. In real life it can lead to lots of wasted time.

Asking someone to talk through a problem like those discussed is often very useful. It gives you an insight into how they think, the background knowledge they can draw on and their understanding of accuracy of data. It's fairly obvious when someone's bullshitting (especially if they talked through the process with you), and any good candidate will be honest about the inaccuracies inherent in their assumption.

Re:Back of the Envelope Calculations [pdf] by bargl on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @12:49PM (#5519353)
I've actually had a professor do this to us in a class. It is a very effective way to show that you can understand what order of magnitude to expect from an answer.

This means that when I go and plug the orbit of a satellite into STK, I'm already looking for an answer within a certain level of precision. While this isn't good enough for an answer to "how much stress does the bolt that holds down the payload have to be capable of withstanding" it does give you a sense of what that answer should be.

This is a very useful tool for realizing when your equation is returning complete crap because you are using the wrong unit (as pointed out by tolkenadult and the Mars probe example).

Re:Back of the Envelope Calculations [pdf] by pacaro on Tuesday April 09, 2013 @01:13PM (#5519511)
I had a math(s) teacher when I was about 11, who would use the phrase "sit on your protractor" to talk about getting inside a geometry problem and asking yourself "does my solution roughly make sense".

I still think in those terms, asking whether the answer to a problem, whether a SWAG, estimate, or careful calculation, could actually be correct