News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by nkrisc on Friday July 31, 2026 @12:21PM (#49125138)
> Are we supposed to accept the idea that an IV drug user sharing needles contracts HIV and they never have to work again even though they'll be getting medication which completely suppresses the virus and will leave a largely normal lifespan?

Is that the price of the “right” people being exempted? Then sure.

Also simply having HIV doesn’t mean you’re terminally ill.

Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by wang_li on Friday July 31, 2026 @12:26PM (#49125217)
HIV is literally called out in the subhead of the linked web page. If you bothered to read the article and get a sense of what is being argued in court, you would understand that there is nothing outre here.
Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by Catloafdev on Friday July 31, 2026 @12:30PM (#49125294)
If you bothered to read the article, you'd understand why this is, in fact, a problem.
Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by nkrisc on Friday July 31, 2026 @05:39PM (#49128825)
I did read the article. It mentions HIV/AIDS. The comment I replied to said only HIV, and as they noted, HIV alone doesn’t necessarily imply any ill health effects at all. However some people with HIV who then develop AIDS may in fact be terminally ill.

The key point is a diagnoses of a terminal illness.

Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by snow_mac on Friday July 31, 2026 @12:26PM (#49125220)
Maybe your argument works for a few specific cases, what about those that do not meet that? What about someone with stage 4 cancer who needs radiation and will likely live a year or two longer without treatment? Without treatment they can't recover, without recovering they can't go to work; their body is literally dying.

With treatment they might be able to live, work and recover. That is what the article is saying. Without insurance people die from cancer. With insurance some people do not die. If we cut their insurance due to more red tape, we're condemning those to death.

Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by wang_li on Friday July 31, 2026 @12:35PM (#49125375)
The policy being argued exempts such people from the work requirement.

People who are not exempt can meet the work requirements through a variety of different activities from part-time work earning $580/month, or 80 hours through a combination of part-time work, volunteer work, and care giving to dependents.

https://www.chcs.org/resource/a-summary-of-national-medicaid...

Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by whiddershins on Friday July 31, 2026 @12:27PM (#49125249)
They would meet the requirements to not have to work. Having nothing to do with terminally ill status and everything to do with the things you just listed. The article doesn't say anyone is proposing to change that.
Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by Catloafdev on Friday July 31, 2026 @12:26PM (#49125227)
Weird that you comment on rage bait and end your comment with the idea that this group of people are all a bunch of worthless drug users.
Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by vzqx on Friday July 31, 2026 @12:30PM (#49125286)
Medicaid defines terminally ill as under 6 months to live. So there's no risk of someone mooching off the system for decades.
Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by bcjdjsndon on Friday July 31, 2026 @12:28PM (#49125255)
Parkinson's lol do you know what that actually looks like? It's degenerative. In a country where only the poor are expected to do all the work, seems fair to me that when they cannot work, the state provides them at least a meagre allowance. What exactly should they do, waste away and starve to death? Pay for it with the money from some billionaire who doesn't work for a living
Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by quickthrowman on Friday July 31, 2026 @12:31PM (#49125310)
It all depends on how “a terminal diagnosis” is defined.

Is someone that is 30 years old, HIV positive, and on antiretrovirals with a low viral load considered a terminal diagnosis? HIV may end their life in 40 years but they’re clearly capable of working.

The article does say “medically frail” people are exempted, so Stage 4 pancreatic cancer would be enough to exempt someone from the rules, but where the line is drawn does matter.

Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by deepsun on Friday July 31, 2026 @12:25PM (#49125212)
Don't know why people downvote and flag your comment, vouched for it.

HN votes are a not designed to be "agree/disagree", they supposed to mark interesting comments that spark curiosity, even if I disagree with them. Your comment is the only one like that here.

Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by kelnos on Friday July 31, 2026 @12:33PM (#49125326)
pg and mods have stated that using votes as agree/disagree is perfectly fine.

Regardless, I don't think the GP comment was particularly interesting or insightful. First they complain the article is rage bait, and then end the comment with rage bait of their own. (Way to anchor "terminally ill person" as "junkie".)

Re:Admin: Terminally Ill Patients Aren't Exempt from Medicai... by wang_li on Friday July 31, 2026 @12:26PM (#49125228)
Arigatou