News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:US Department of Justice has officially reclassified cann... by oompydoompy74 on Thursday April 23, 2026 @10:24AM (#47876127)
Yeah you can buy those legally online and plant them in your yard right now. This take is based on all of human history until the last 2 - 300 years.
Re:US Department of Justice has officially reclassified cann... by john_strinlai on Thursday April 23, 2026 @10:38AM (#47876294)
>So it should be OK to sell hemlock or nightshade

just going to highlight this part:

"At the minimum, [...] for my own personal consumption."

Re:US Department of Justice has officially reclassified cann... by vel0city on Thursday April 23, 2026 @10:36AM (#47876258)
> So it should be OK to sell hemlock or nightshade and other all-natural plant-based poisons?

Sure, why not? Especially the plant itself, I see little reason to regulate it any more than any other kind of plant. Maybe require good labeling is in place, but other than that why not?

If anything one would regulate cultivating it in the US due to it being an invasive species, and really shouldn't be grown in North America. But the cats out of the bag on that one, its already all over the place.

Re:US Department of Justice has officially reclassified cann... by cucumber3732842 on Thursday April 23, 2026 @10:26AM (#47876147)
>So it should be OK to sell hemlock or nightshade and other all-natural plant-based poisons?

Rofl. Yeah sure but who's buying? Approximately nobody. So there's no harm and not even a problem for regulation to solve.

>Maybe even give them to others?

Already illegal depending upon the details of "give".

>Why is it any more or less acceptable to regulate the use of chemistry equipment than of agricultural products?

Because speculative "someone might" or "at scale we've noted that <some numbers near the noise floor>" claims are not sufficient ground for restricting the freedom of individuals. Those who argue otherwise have bad morals.

When you start talking about widespread industry and known, defined and obviously present harms (see for example all those pictures of odd colored rivers in the 50s-70s, use of lead paint in residential settings, etc) it's a different story but the bar for regulating what one may possess and use/consume in the privacy of their own home ought to be many orders of magnitude higher.

Re:US Department of Justice has officially reclassified cann... by tsimionescu on Thursday April 23, 2026 @11:14AM (#47876725)
> Because speculative "someone might" or "at scale we've noted that <some numbers near the noise floor>" claims are not sufficient ground for restricting the freedom of individuals.

That's not what I asked. I asked what it is, specifically, about agricultural practices that is supposed to make them more worthy of protection than chemical processes. Specifically, why does the GP think it's more ok to ban people from making crystal meth at home than it is to ban them from growing coca leaves or weed.

Note that, of course, meth is much worse for you than either of the previous two. But GP's point was not about harm, but about the supposed right to grow any plant you want.

Re:US Department of Justice has officially reclassified cann... by vel0city on Thursday April 23, 2026 @02:54PM (#47879980)
> it's more ok to ban people from making crystal meth at home

I don't see too many homes exploding because they had a few hemlock plants growing in a planter on the porch.

Regulating industrial chemical manufacturing to places other than residential areas makes a lot of sense. I don't really want my neighbor fabricating toxic sludge next to my backyard garden and where my kids are playing.

Re:US Department of Justice has officially reclassified cann... by oompydoompy74 on Thursday April 23, 2026 @10:28AM (#47876177)
Fully agree with this. Well put.
Re:US Department of Justice has officially reclassified cann... by Woshiwuja on Thursday April 23, 2026 @10:25AM (#47876140)
Yes it should be OK, poisoning people is still illegal