News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by fncypants on Thursday February 13, 2025 @11:36AM (#43037815)
So let's tear everything down good and bad because in an organization at a scale of trillions of dollars, we found $50 million we don't like.
Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by toasteros on Thursday February 13, 2025 @11:43AM (#43037947)
Not to mention that the radicalisation and terrorism USAID helped prevent from fomenting has likely saved the US many trillions in rebuilding efforts and healthcare.
Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by lowkey_ on Thursday February 13, 2025 @11:52AM (#43038086)
Can you share details on that?

USAID, as far as I can tell, is stoking anti-US sentiment in many places by importing their own cultural values, and that's a known thing State Department officials have commented on.

Additionally, to be specific on even worse activity:

A few months ago, $9M of USAID went to an organization affiliated with Al Qaeda.

The Middle East Forum recently found $164M in USAID grants to radical organizations.

Apart from that, we've since found lots of evidence of USAID funding Hamas specifically. $900K was given days before the October 7th attack.

There's even pictures of Al Shabaab terrorists inside a USAID tent.

Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by lowkey_ on Thursday February 13, 2025 @11:42AM (#43037920)
No, I think you're misunderstanding.

It looks like in a week, they uncovered over $100M, maybe $200M in fraud (I'm not keeping close track), if you count million-dollar "executive coaching" contracts as fraud (I do). It's most likely telling their friend outside the government "hey, I got some extra budget — you be my 'executive coach,' and we'll split the proceeds."

They've found billions in things that we should not be spending our money on while our own people die of drug overdoses, homeless in the street. Things "we don't like" as you say.

Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by freejazz on Thursday February 13, 2025 @11:48AM (#43038019)
But those are insignificant portions of the federal budget and nothing indicates that the repercussions of the wanton tear-thru of federal agencies is going to be a net-gain for the US.
Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by lowkey_ on Thursday February 13, 2025 @11:55AM (#43038125)
It will take years to understand the amount of corruption & waste in the federal government. We can agree that these numbers found each day are 'insignificant', but it adds up, and I think we need a hard reset on the size & scope of government. That's what was voted in by the people.
Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by freejazz on Thursday February 13, 2025 @04:14PM (#43041452)
Sorry, but I'm highly skeptical that the political figures who are doing things like unconstitutionally firing inspectors general have any good interest at heart. It's completely contrary to what you are suggesting is going on. There is no good faith effort here to root out corruption. It is an effort to dismantle things that stand in the way of further graft.
Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by MyOutfitIsVague on Thursday February 13, 2025 @12:43PM (#43038837)
I keep hearing them talking about "fraud", but I've yet to see it substantiated. Where are the reports? Where is the evidence? If we consider Musk to be an unreliable actor (I do), then I need more than his word.
Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by ModernMech on Thursday February 13, 2025 @09:59PM (#43044293)
> If we consider Musk to be an unreliable actor (I do),

Musk said himself yesterday that he expects to be wrong, he has been wrong, and we should all scrutinize him thoroughly. So even he admits he's an unreliable actor.

Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by lowkey_ on Friday February 14, 2025 @03:40PM (#43052849)
We like to use the principle of charitable interpretation on here, and to be charitable, I think it's really clear he was saying that everybody should expect to be wrong sometimes, has been wrong, and should be scrutinized thoroughly.

To label someone as an unreliable actor is different than using our own free will and minds to analyze actions and determine truth.

Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by ModernMech on Friday February 14, 2025 @04:57PM (#43053545)
Competent people use processes, procedures, and safeguards to minimize human error. It's easy to say "everyone makes mistakes" when you're just a guy, but when you're wielding the powers of the presidency in such an unbalanced and unchecked way, he should be reassuring us how he will assure the trustworthiness of his proclamations going forward. Instead, he gestures vaguely to the human condition.

How can you say he's not an unreliable actor? The man has unlimited resources, power, and the best information available to him. He also is in a position of dizzying public trust right now, so really he should be making the utmost effort to be above reproach. "Aw shucks man, what do you expect, I'm just human after all" is not reassuring. And I'm sorry that's not a charitable enough take, but we are far past the time for benefit of the doubt.

Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by lowkey_ on Friday February 14, 2025 @03:46PM (#43052899)
Does the tens of millions in "executive coaching" and "strategic communication" contracts really not look like fraud to you, or do you not believe that they're there because it's DOGE reporting it?

I think they're moving as fast as possible right now, and it takes a while to investigate & report.

Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by lowkey_ on Friday February 14, 2025 @04:02PM (#43053041)
Also, found an interesting source from the federal government during the Biden administration:

https://www.gao.gov/blog/federal-government-made-236-billion...

Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by basementcat on Thursday February 13, 2025 @11:47AM (#43038010)
The link between the "trans opera in Colombia" and USAID seems tenuous at best.

https://www.thepinknews.com/2025/02/05/usaid-spending-list-t...

Still seems weird to threaten the lives of over 20 million people over this.

Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by lowkey_ on Thursday February 13, 2025 @12:01PM (#43038213)
ThePinkNews doesn't seem like a fantastic source but I gave it a sincere effort and read through, and yes, it seems tenuously true.

None of this is okay to me, as an American, while my own citizens die in the street, homeless, of drug overdoses.

This money needs to be spent on our own country or, at the least, intelligently on our national interests.

Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by mmcwilliams on Thursday February 13, 2025 @11:46AM (#43037993)
If you have specifics about these fraud cases you're alleging, please add the details. You shouldn't let the people you're accusing of this specific crime go unpunished because you won't make their details public.
Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by lowkey_ on Thursday February 13, 2025 @11:59AM (#43038201)
It's all over X, including from the official DOGE account.

Here's a couple:

On the morning of 2/3/25, 20 consulting contracts, mostly focused on "strategic communication" and "executive coaching," were terminated for immediate savings of $26mm.

On 2/10/25, the Department of Education terminated 89 contracts worth $881mm. One contractor was paid $1.5mm to "observe mailing and clerical operations at a mail center."

These things take months to years, and I don't believe we'll see fraud cases when it's been less than a month since the DOGE operation has started. If it's not fraud, it's grossly negligent with taxpayer money (which is not a crime), but I would bet at least a few of those sketchy contracts were with friends and former colleagues of the government bureaucrats in question.

Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by mmcwilliams on Sunday February 16, 2025 @01:35PM (#43070354)
So your evidence of fraud includes contracts that were not provably fraudulent and just things you deem unnecessary? And it's your "bet" that these were "sketchy"? Is there a law against friends and former colleagues of government officials getting contracts? I imagine that would create several problems for the current administration.
Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by unethical_ban on Thursday February 13, 2025 @11:40AM (#43037886)
So again, not fraud. Just things they don't like.

And rather than set up a team to look for it and target the things they don't like, which would be more reasonable and more legal, they decided to shut entire agencies down and break 100% of operations.

PS it's a good thing that USAID is not a part of State.

Re:DOGE Has Started Gutting a Key US Technology Agency by lowkey_ on Thursday February 13, 2025 @11:47AM (#43038003)
On USAID being independent from State:

I personally would like our taxpayer-funded dollars, even if some insist on sending them overseas, to at least serve our national interest.

I know we set up USAID to counteract Communist aid from the USSR, but what do you think is the ongoing rationale for its independence from State? State is stuck fielding lots of questions from angry nations over USAID activity.