News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Be My Eyes’ AI assistant starts rolling out by anonylizard on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @10:18AM (#37675036)
Get off your high horse.

AI is plainly revolutionary for the blind. You don't need 'high level prosthetics', you just need a smartphone with a camera, and you can now see the world.

AI is also revolutionary for the deaf, neural speech to text is getting so good, that soon 'hearing aids' will be secondary, you can just read from a screen with live subtitles.

You are pretty much making stuff up with " Will it become the accessible norm?Nope." ChatGPT plus only costs $20 a month. How more 'accessible' can it possibly get? Has there ever ever ever been a technology for the deaf and blind as revolutionary AND cheap as this?

If you have some anti-corporate agenda, fine, but self-righteousness gives you no right to lie.

Re:Be My Eyes’ AI assistant starts rolling out by Spivak on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @10:30AM (#37675183)
> hearing aids' will be secondary, you can just read from a screen with live subtitles

I already do this on Discord, my bot listens to discord calls, saves the audio in chunks, send them off to whisper and I get a neat tidy live-ish transcription. It's a game-changer honestly because combination APD and ADHD being able to go back in the conversion and see what I missed or came out garbled is amazing. Whisper is so good compared to the previous state-of-art it's nuts. It understands tone, slang. My next project is to see if I can get it to detect different speakers.

Re:Be My Eyes’ AI assistant starts rolling out by RyanAdamas on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @11:52AM (#37676523)
And all it's going to cost the rest of us is our ability to free and critically think.

No biggie.

Accessibility is accountability. How accountable is 'OpenAI' to anyone other than it's massive investor Microsoft? You want me to be self-righteous so you can be dismissive of the actual path we are travelling on, likely because you benefit from it; and most likely not because you're blind.

"Anti-corporate agenda" is a pro-human perspective. Difficult to call people liars without being utterly delusional, when there is a clear track record of corporate abuse of purpose.

"Don't be evil!" That turned out well, huh?

Life loves irony; and the truth is, we will grant the blind vision only for them to see it all collapse. Congrats on being a real champion of the disabled.

Re:Be My Eyes’ AI assistant starts rolling out by capableweb on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @10:17AM (#37675020)
In general I think you're right, but maybe Be My Eyes is not the best example? The company has been around since 2015 helping people since day one, hasn't seem to shift focus in any of these 8 years, and has a huge amount of users using it daily to be helped.
Re:Be My Eyes’ AI assistant starts rolling out by letmevoteplease on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @10:19AM (#37675042)
"Open AI does not store the photos or chats after processing them. None of your photos or chats are being used to train the AI."

https://support.bemyeyes.com/hc/en-us/articles/1813313480910...

Re:Be My Eyes’ AI assistant starts rolling out by RyanAdamas on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @11:58AM (#37676632)
>>How are photos and chat interactions processed and stored, and who will have access to my data? Be My Eyes initially processes your photos and chats to (a) send them to Open AI for further processing, (b) provide Be My AI’s descriptions, and (c) give you follow up options. Open AI processes the photos and chats to provide the AI response.

During our beta testing, Be My Eyes stores all photos and chat interactions on encrypted servers so that we can review them, if necessary, based on tester feedback. That helps us build a better service based on your feedback. It also allows us to address any safety or content issues that may come up. Open AI does not store the photos or chats after processing them. None of your photos or chats are being used to train the AI.

The storage and use of your photos and chats by Be My Eyes are governed by our privacy policy.

That, does not mean the data isn't being mined for data, or processed into other models. The data may not be directly training AI, that doesn't mean the correlations aren't. Also, the key clarification here is "During Beta Testing".

>>Governed by our privacy policy: >>>>The one exception is that if you use Be My AI or another Service powered by third-party artificial intelligence technology, and the images or video you submit contain personal information, that information could be processed by our third-party provider to train and improve the artificial intelligence technology. >>>>We also work with third-party ad networks and advertising partners to deliver advertising and personalized content on other websites and services, across other devices, and possibly on our Services. These parties may collect information directly from a browser or device when an individual visits our Services through cookies or other data collection technologies.

Obfuscation is the word of the day.

Re:Be My Eyes’ AI assistant starts rolling out by Nfthero on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @10:19AM (#37675040)
This company actually has real value for people.

Better than a million others.

Google and co do not need a company like this to train anything and this company probably did not train anything themselves as it's not feasible.

And honestly what's your problem? The image detection trained by us is now good enough to help blind people navigating their life's.

And if this would be too expensive than it's either the market or the state which will fix any pricing issues.

And thanks to ai and the internet those companies even have to be globally efficient and not just in a local market

Re:Be My Eyes’ AI assistant starts rolling out by 2dvisio on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @10:23AM (#37675097)
Agree with other comments. The company has been providing real tangible value to its users via a very dense network of volunteers. I know that because my wife has been using it (as volunteer) and helping people very frequently. I hope this experiment with AI is successful for them.
Re:Be My Eyes’ AI assistant starts rolling out by sebzim4500 on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @10:22AM (#37675089)
Blindly assuming is an asshole is no better than trusting everyone you meet.

Do not confuse cynicism with insight.

Re:Be My Eyes’ AI assistant starts rolling out by RyanAdamas on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @12:08PM (#37676797)
Don't confuse progress with profit.