News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Germany opposes EU plans for client-side scanning by lhoff on Thursday March 02, 2023 @11:38AM (#34998020)
> Hartmann either does not understand encryption, or client-based content scanning. There's a good chance Hartmann doesn't understand either :-(

I think that is debatable and depends on your viewpoint. If you only look at the technical process of end-to-end encryption it is, indeed, not weakend by client-side scanning since that happens prior to the encryption. If you, however look at it from the perspective of the use case (sending information privately without information leakage) it is weakened. Client-side scanning only makes sense if, in case of a match, some authority is informed. This is by definition information leakage. On a first glance it looks like a ok compromise in the case of CSAM but if the technology is in place it can only go downhill from there and the next step is usually terrorism followed by capital crimes. The later two categories can be abused depending on the definition which heavily differs depending on which European country we are talking about. Also if the technology is forced in place by the European market, there is very little that stops other less liberal countries to use the same technology against whatever they don't like. So it's the usual slippery slope argument with the additional caveat that a lot of child protection agencies are not convinced that it would make an important difference and that the resources should be allocated elsewhere.

Re:Germany opposes EU plans for client-side scanning by wkat4242 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @11:37AM (#34998002)
The problem is that for it to actually work you will need to take control away from the users over all their computing devices. Otherwise they can simply circumvent it.

It would mean a model as closed as iOS, but for all mobiles and desktop platforms.

I will personally never let that happen. This is way too draconian a measure to solve a problem that will not go away anyway. The predators will just go offline again.

Re:Germany opposes EU plans for client-side scanning by gchq-7703 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @11:24AM (#34997796)
False positives / false negatives are important to note. It is likely that they're saying that out of 100,000 scanned files, 10,000 to 20,000 will not include child sexual abuse.
Re:Germany opposes EU plans for client-side scanning by hnhg on Thursday March 02, 2023 @11:35AM (#34997970)
You would have to look at it from the perspective of the base rate (for low incidence) to properly understand what that means for the wider population: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_rate_fallacy
Re:Germany opposes EU plans for client-side scanning by hexo on Thursday March 02, 2023 @11:33AM (#34997951)
id say 10-20% of all content is expected to be misclassified
Re:Germany opposes EU plans for client-side scanning by devmor on Thursday March 02, 2023 @11:28AM (#34997869)
If every agency and government with access to this technology could be trusted to only use it for CSAM it would be the easiest no-brainer to approve and turn on immediately.

But they can't. It can easily be used to target people for political and social reasons just as easily, and once that Pandora's Box is opened it can never be closed.

For the most topical example, imagine it being used in a conservative US State to target images of people not conforming to the gender they are expected to.

Re:Germany opposes EU plans for client-side scanning by slackdog on Thursday March 02, 2023 @11:35AM (#34997973)
Even if the government exercised restraint and only used this technology in the manner they presently advocate for, a 10% false positive rate, presumably each resulting in an invasive investigation, is way too high.