News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by ryanklee on Saturday December 10, 2022 @09:23AM (#33932845)
Holy moly. People cannot escape cognitive biases even by knowing about cognitive biases. This includes you. It seems that you think you have somehow transcended this condition. This is just another bias. And this particular one is maybe the most insidious of all because it convinces you you're better than most on a fundamental level and protects you from introspection and criticism. Seek humility.
Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by fourfoursix on Saturday December 10, 2022 @11:37AM (#33933992)
How so. I simply said, "consider the possibility." Because scientifically. These are possibilities. Realistic ones in fact. I directly picked them for their controversy. I am aware of the direction they run counter to the norms. Are you aware of your biases? Are you aware how inline with cultural norms and biases that your opinions are?

At times, many of these things weren't controversial. How do you know that the current thinking is correct? Based off what science? Or is it bias?

HN isn't better. It's biased.

Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by ryanklee on Saturday December 10, 2022 @12:15PM (#33934374)
The fact that your comment is flagged and dead should give you pause. The fact that it doesn't give you pause should give you pause. The fact that you think I am objecting to your specific assertions rather than the mode of assertions should give you pause. Yet, it seems that self-regards of epistemic superiority is the only unstable fuel you need to travel down a lonely road. Good luck.
Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by fourfoursix on Saturday December 10, 2022 @12:42PM (#33934673)
>The fact that your comment is flagged and dead should give you pause. The fact that it doesn't give you pause should give you pause.

There is no pause. I KNOW the COST of my beliefs. It is a high cost and your reaction and the flag is a small PART of that cost.

I live a life of lies. Externally I believe none of these things and I pretend to be normal just like you. But internally I see darkness everywhere.

Keep in mind, I don't care if my beliefs are implemented to make a better world. I could care less. In fact most of the beliefs I hold, I feel if the world knew the truth it would be worse off for everybody. I'm not really an opponent against any group here.

>"Yet, it seems that self-regards of epistemic superiority is the only unstable fuel you need to travel down a lonely road."

We both know that epistemic superiority is not worth it for any human. You underestimate the sacrifices involved with believing in these things. Nobody makes that choice. I get what your saying but you are disregarding the cost way too much here. A sense of superiority is not reward enough for the price one must pay to believe in these things.

I am what I am because I cannot un-believe what I think is true. I have no choice. Can you not believe 1 + 1 = 2? To me the conclusions are inescapable. But of course it could be that I am biased. Biased people do not know they are biased. Whether or not I am biased, I can assure you that I am not where I am by choice. I am where I am because I have no choice.

>The fact that you think I am objecting to your specific assertions rather than the mode of assertions should give you pause.

This DOES give me pause. Please describe to me in detail what you mean by "Mode."

Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by selimthegrim on Saturday December 10, 2022 @04:02PM (#33936758)
For one example you might want to consider how Asian males are considered in Latin America as opposed to the US (hint: a lot more desirable)
Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by fourfivefour on Saturday December 10, 2022 @04:37PM (#33937092)
Valid info. I have not considered it. Economic status and size are factors in female attraction. Asians are generally higher in economic status, statistically speaking, and latin americans are generally poorer and smaller in size so they are more comparable in stature to East Asians. This makes logical sense to what I already know. However it doesn't invalidate the German Sheppard theory. North Americans are generally larger than East Asians and the wealth gap is not as large.

Still all of this is besides the point. Without knowing the latin american thing, my conclusion and theory is valid in terms of the probability of being true. But people dismiss it because of bias, not because of evidence or logic.

Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by selimthegrim on Sunday December 11, 2022 @12:56AM (#33940498)
Asians have a more positive image in Latin America because the overwhelming impression is that of Bruce Lee machismo, Peruvian Chinese and Japanese Brazilians and not Hollywood casting
Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by fouroneone on Sunday December 11, 2022 @01:12PM (#33945699)
I don't think that image beats out the Caucasian white male from the US even within Latin America.

The hierarchy of the racial dating game is still consistent.

Also the situation in the US is not simply false impressions by hollywood casting. Bro, hollywood casting is reactionary to the situation in the states. It's much much deeper than that.

Asian females born in the united states... a huge number of them are Racist against their own race. Many date white people, and many refuse to date asian males. This is much more then some false perception.

Asian Females have very very in depth and realistic perceptions about asian males given the fact they have Fathers and brothers that they grew up with. The choice they make is done NOT because of false perception projected by hollywood or whatever.

You have to get scientific and realistic about this. White people fucking asians easily talk about this behind closed doors, but as an Asian... it's much harder to see reality BECAUSE of IDENTITY.

Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by ethanbond on Saturday December 10, 2022 @09:08AM (#33932736)
“I am observing from an objective position” is the surest sign of a deeply compromised thinker.
Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by BlueTemplar on Saturday December 10, 2022 @09:51AM (#33933074)
Yeah, while I would in theory applaud the example of "scientist" that Graham gave, let's not delude ourselves, it's quite vulnerable to exactly this kind of failure mode. Some other examples : scientism, "angry atheism", "rationalism" (mostly for the arrogant and historically opposite meaning for that last one)...
Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by fourfoursix on Saturday December 10, 2022 @11:49AM (#33934111)
Except that, that quotation is a fabrication. It was never stated by me, nor was it stated in the article.

It is also logically flawed. If there exists in this world someone who was truly objective. Would they know they're objective?

Knowing if oneself is objective or not is in itself an objective calculation. If that person was truly objective, then the answer is yes, he would know. But I get your point, there are many who think they are "objective" but they are not.

Mind you, one test for objectivity is to see whether your thoughts are the result of parroting cultural norms or if they arise from objective thinking. If your thoughts are objective there is no rule that such thoughts should imitate cultural norms. One will notice that ones opinions are "different" so to say.

My points pass those tests. It doesn't mean I am "objective" but it is evidence for it.

Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by ethanbond on Saturday December 10, 2022 @11:57AM (#33934181)
No, believing things other people don’t believe is actually not evidence of objectivity.
[dead]
Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by ethanbond on Saturday December 10, 2022 @12:30PM (#33934527)
Your ultimate objective should be thriving, ideally for you and as many people and creatures as you can afford to account for. Truth is valuable because since the enlightenment period it has seemed to be extremely valuable in securing thriving.

If you instead are picking Truth and Lack Of Bias over, for example, a rich social life, I’d suggest you are putting the cart before the horse.

I hope you find your place with the right mix of imperfect belongingness and imperfect veracity! Both are important :)

Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by fouroneone on Saturday December 10, 2022 @01:36PM (#33935335)
Oh, It's completely too late for me. I cannot unbelieve what I believe.

I already live a life of lies. Nobody knows what I believe and I lie to seem normal and socialize-able. I also don't hold any strong desire to "implement" my beliefs. It's just a perspective.. I am an observer with opinions and I don't care to be any sort of activist.

I largely agree with your last post. However it's too late. I no longer believe what I believe out of choice. I have no choice in what I believe. Once these truths crystallize in your head as truths, they stay that way unless someone can point out any logical flaws. Thinking back it would've been better to not have gone down the path of being cursed with knowledge.

I actually wish to be part of certain religious communities because of the great social benefits that come with being part of said groups. But certain knowledge makes me unable to fully participate because the lie becomes to great.

Imagine praying and worshiping and studying about an entity that I believe is a complete fabrication... just for social benefits. The time sunk into living that lie is too great. So usually I'm part of more moderate groups that mostly avoid these topics. But these groups tend to be more ephemeral.

Humans need a shared lie/belief to bond deeply, and if you lose the ability to lie to yourself it's harder to join these more close knit groups.

However as I grow older, I contemplate more and more whether the lie is worth it. Maybe one day when I'm an old lonely man like I'm 70, I'll live the lie and join one of those religious groups.

>Your ultimate objective should be thriving, ideally for you and as many people and creatures as you can afford to account for.

I want to comment on this part specifically. Because there's a problem here. Being aware that thriving is more important then truth and living by that principle means that you are aware that your concept of what is true is on shaky grounds. You KNOW you made sacrifices to what your truth is in order to thrive. You are aware you are lying to yourself and that defeats the nature of the lie.

To truly thrive in my opinion, you must be unaware and ignorant of these concepts. You must not think about or even be aware about the orthogonality of happiness and knowledge. Just go with the flow. These are the people that are truly happy.

From your post it seems it's a little too late for you as well, you're not as deep as me but you're somewhat down that path. You're aware of the shared lie, you just choose not to think about it too deeply. That's an ok place to be. You might not have contemplated about these topics to deeply and have the "I'm not an expert so I don't know" attitude and it works out. Just know that each step forward down that path is permanent, there is no turning back.

Anyway I brought up this thread, the main purpose was basically to point out that although what graham says is true, giving up your identity for rationality has a High Cost. But this point is lost because my "6 bullet points" (designed with the intent to point out our own biases) was way to visceral. It shows how inescapable bias really is.

I'm actually hoping to meet someone like-minded. Someone who "gets it" on the same level that I do. But that seems less and less likely given the flag.

Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by narag on Saturday December 10, 2022 @03:31PM (#33936504)
I believe that the answer you seek is in the article. You're too attached to a sick mindset. It's better to stop overthinking and doing something that have more pleasant effects (for you) than writting long-winded comments here. Or maybe not.
Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by fourfivefour on Saturday December 10, 2022 @04:40PM (#33937109)
I don't think you read my comment or the article carefully. The extreme end of that article, giving up all your identity is my "sick mindset". That is the ultimate conclusion.

You might as well not comment if you're not going to read anything. I don't care for you comment otherwise. Better for you to start actually thinking and stop mistaking that for "over thinking", because your reply indicates you haven't.

Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by narag on Saturday December 10, 2022 @08:03PM (#33938848)
...giving up all your identity is my "sick mindset".

So drop it already. The article isn't about "the extreme end" anyway. There's a middle ground between being a soulless robot and a sheep, isn't there?

Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by fouroneone on Sunday December 11, 2022 @12:57PM (#33945546)
Drop what. Again you didn't read the article. The article isn't about how far you go. It's only about how identity is correlated with stupidity. The more identity you have the stupider you are.

It doesn't talk about taking it to the extreme.

This isn't something you can drop. There are caricature movie characters that are in similar predicaments. If I name them you will understand. Rick Sanchez and Thanos. The term is cursed knowledge. You cannot undo knowledge gained, once you have it, it sticks with you.

Thanos is a villain. The slaughter he conducts is horrifying, yet his logic has a truth that he cannot deny. In the end it's the avengers who delude themselves.

Rick Sanchez would be more similar to where I am. Knowledge of the cold hard truths and apathy towards everything.

Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by ethanbond on Saturday December 10, 2022 @07:46PM (#33938730)
I’ll leave you with this my friend. I don’t think you should feel lost or too far gone :)

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/pragmatism/

Re:Keep Your Identity Small (2009) by fouroneone on Sunday December 11, 2022 @01:02PM (#33945597)
I don't feel lost.

I feel everyone else is lost. THAT is my problem.

That philosophy doesn't mean anything to me. It may define what I feel but in the end it's just a word. Do you read it and suddenly come to the conclusion that eugenics is a valid strategy?

People claim to pragmatic, but true pragmatism involves some horrible stuff. See my 6 points.