Ok, what will you do about the people who actively refuse to accept that support?
We are talking about non-rational, mentally ill, addicted people. You can't just offer support. If that worked, this problem would not exist.
The problem is that shelter is always offered with strings attached - you need to be actively seeking employment, you need to listen to our sermons, you can't use if you accept the housing, you can only sleep here for three nights then we need the bed for someone else.
If SF built some new high-rises and offered every homeless person a condo free of charge that they will personally own after some amount of occupancy you'd pretty much solve homelessness and put a significant dent in mental health issues overnight.
And if that does not happen you can always say that some strings were attached after all: the requirement to pay utility bills, the requirement to dispose of trash, the requirement not to have open fire and/or chemical labs inside, the requirement not to assault neighbors and passersby etc. etc. After all there are always some "strings" required to live in the society and even more of those when you require that the society provides you with everything you need for nothing in return.
The fact of the matter is, there are two populations of homeless, and while they are not defined the presence or absence of drug use and mental illness, there is a correlation. These populations are those that will accept housing and shelter, and those that won't.
The former population is easy to deal with. Give them housing until they are able to obtain it on their own.
But what do you do about people who would rather stay on the streets? Let's split this "unwilling" population once more. There are the unwilling that are unobtrusive, don't bother anyone or hurt anything. Not a problem. But what about the unwilling that are a public nuisance? Erratic, violent, etc.?
What, realistically, do you do about them? They won't go, but they can't stay. Define "long-term public support" for a population of people that is dangerous to the public and unwilling not to be. Eventually they will hurt someone or damage property and end up in prison anyway. Should we not address a clear public safety hazard preemptively?
Yes yes, slippery slope. Care will need to be taken, people will fall through the cracks anyway. Every system has cracks, but god knows the current one has big gaping gashes. We are already failing these people. I don't know that incarceration would fail them worse.
Right, the entire population of the US, which means solutions has to come from the federal government because of freedom of movement within the US.
The only solution available for state, county, and city governments is incarceration. Unless they want to blow up their budgets and see people who pay into the system move out and people who are net recipients of benefits move in.
Canada never tried to mass incarceration imprison-away the problem and they're rapidly discovering that they actually need some criminal charges and some incarceration or people don't care to improve. Taking fentanyl is literally the best feeling thing in life and you expect a junkie to just stop living in a free-drug camp?
The Netherlands and Portugal though have an incarceration-based rehab program. They don't ask the junkie if they're ready, they pick up anyone drugged out in public. But their programs work because there's essentially no other choice. You can't just refuse to detox because they don't give you free Fentanyl like Vancouver and SF. You can't support a junkie by giving them poison. They wean you, in 3-9 months, with long-halflife opioid agonists and then you spend years, sober, learning to live clean.
The policies you support are killing people with kindness.