[deleted]
Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman
by raganwald on Monday October 31, 2011 @04:28PM
(#3178890)
This is what we call an "Ad Hominem Tu Quoque.” How does it validate or invalidate his words?
[deleted]
raganwald is agreeing with Dave Winer in arguing against the personal ridiculing of RMS. The validity of this argument does not hinge on whether Dave Winer is being hypocritical in making it or not; one can be a hypocrite and still be correct.
In other words, if you want to argue against raganwald and Dave Winer, that RMS should be ridiculed, you need to come up with something that logically supports that, not just assert "Dave Winer is a bully also". This assertion does not advance your argument.
[deleted]
Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman
by raganwald on Monday October 31, 2011 @05:02PM
(#3179045)
Thank you for your feedback. You may find the following interesting:
http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem
I used the expression specifically because it has been much discussed here on Hacker News. Another of historical interest is:
А у вас негров линчуют
Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman
by saraid216 on Monday October 31, 2011 @05:29PM
(#3179171)
Ignorance is not a sufficient excuse to feel "bullied and ridiculed". If you can't be bothered to educate yourself, then why are you worth talking to? If the timing is poor for looking it up, politely stating that you don't understand the jargon and would like an explanation is a fair response. Saying, "I don't know this information, and the fact that you have it is offensive to me," is the very essence of anti-intellectualism.
Re:Dave Winer: Why I stand up for Stallman
by mturmon on Monday October 31, 2011 @05:12PM
(#3179087)
I'm allergic to Latin when used to impress, but you should understand (and accept) that a lot of the prior work around rhetoric and argumentation comes from Greek and Latin sources. See also: modus ponens, QED, reductio ad absurdum, a fortiori. All commonly used.
http://lmgtfy.com/?q=Ad+Hominem+Tu+Quoque
[edit] This relates to your point because you are literally one click away from knowing the definition of such phrases. It is no great burden to ask that you occasionally Google phrases that people use, especially when there is not better way of saying it.