News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Moderna’s HIV Vaccine Prepped for Trials in Africa by tux3 on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:12AM (#31445009)
>The level of downvoting and non-engagement about my comments you can observe on HN is just a symptom of a humanity that simply don't care above the surface layer of attention nor care deeply about the human condition and is auto-persuaded, in a self-fulfiling prophethy manner that those topics are already well explored by the institutions

More likely, it is the expected reaction to the fact that crackpottery takes an order of magnitude more effort to debunk than to write. It's okay to have non-mainstream ideas, but the post above is written in a way that's hard to distinguish from crackpottery.

When someone engages with crackpottery and responds point-by-point, the result is likely to be a very long subthread where no one changes their mind. It is a tremendous waste of time, and so empirically this results in silent downvotes.

>a much more efficient process for finding potent ignored research, which is the norm considering half of scientific papers have nearly zero external citations and are therefore a water droplet in the ocean

An enormous amount of studies are bad. There exist a few hidden gems that have zero citations while being high quality, but if you focus only on the existence of the few hidden gems while ignoring the ocean of statistically dubious, p-hacked, or downright fraudulent papers with zero citations, this is terrible bias.

I suspect you have a strong distrust of the mainstream, and you might put too much confidence in the significance of small ignored papers. It is easy to be very excited about breakthrough interventions that reduce all cause mortality by 410%. We all want those breakthrough to be real, and we want the little guy with zero citations to be right against the 'mediocrity'.

But that's bias. The reality is that those papers are almost always wrong, and you do more harm by giving them indiscriminate attention, peddling cures that don't work to vulnerable people.

Re:Moderna’s HIV Vaccine Prepped for Trials in Africa by s1artibartfast on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:56AM (#31445300)
>>The level of downvoting and non-engagement about my comments you can observe on HN is just a symptom of a humanity that simply don't care above the surface layer of attention nor care deeply about the human condition and is auto-persuaded, in a self-fulfiling prophethy manner that those topics are already well explored by the institutions

Part of it is the presentation of your commentary alienates the reader, doesn't inspire confidence, and contains many hallmarks of cranks or conspiracy theorists

- absolute declarative sentences

- run-on sentences

- switching between loosely connected topics

- switching back and forth between social criticisms and scientific evidence

- Flippant language and mocking attitudes (eg lols)

- Self aggrandizement

For all I know you may have a valid scientific point, but you are ringing the same alarm bells as the lunatic on the street-corner.

Re:Moderna’s HIV Vaccine Prepped for Trials in Africa by niemandhier on Friday May 20, 2022 @06:42AM (#31445578)
> however endogenously produced drugs cannot be patented and therefore are not lucrative

You are mistaken. They can and have been in the EU.

I would like to make you and the Hackernews crowed aware of Rule 27 of the The European Patent Convention.

"Biotechnological inventions shall also be patentable if they concern: (a) biological material which is isolated from its natural environment or produced by means of a technical process even if it previously occurred in nature"

Which is clarified in "The European Patent Office's Guidelines for Examination" as: "to find a previously unrecognised substance occurring in nature is... mere discovery and therefore unpatentable. However, if a substance found in nature can be shown to produce a technical effect, it may be patentable. An example of such a case is that of a substance occurring in nature which is found to have an antibiotic effect."

The EU goes even further: You can patent a previously described natural compound for medical uses under Art. 54(4) and Art. 54(5 EPC, assuming that the compund was previously not known to be usable for a particular use case.

I suggest you read https://www.nature.com/articles/s41587-022-01269-3 as well as https://www.epo.org/law-practice/legal-texts/html/epc/2020/e....

Then draft a pitch deck and go VC hunting. The EU market is ca.400 million people, that should be enough.

Re:Moderna’s HIV Vaccine Prepped for Trials in Africa by dekhn on Friday May 20, 2022 @12:32PM (#31449653)
I'm going to have to spend at least 10 minutes today contemplating the implications of "to find a previously unrecognised substance occurring in nature is... mere discovery and therefore unpatentable. However, if a substance found in nature can be shown to produce a technical effect, it may be patentable. An example of such a case is that of a substance occurring in nature which is found to have an antibiotic effect."

that's an important subtlety (specifically, allowing patenting if a substance can be shown to have a "use"). Maybe nature should hire a lawyer and do some preemptive patenting.

Re:Moderna’s HIV Vaccine Prepped for Trials in Africa by niemandhier on Saturday May 21, 2022 @10:47AM (#31458357)
Use and process have to be disclosed as part of the patent, so preemptive actions are hard.
Re:Moderna’s HIV Vaccine Prepped for Trials in Africa by SemanticStrengh on Friday May 20, 2022 @07:23AM (#31445893)
Thanks for sharing, I wasn't aware of that, that is a big news to me. However I'm afraid this is very limited: 1) many peptides are produced by extracting them from cattle organs, here their thymus but see also cerebrolysin for example. The Peptides researchers have often made synthetic analogues, which are similar to the endogenously produced version but can be produced in labs. However not every peptide has a synthetic variant and IIRC thymalin is derived from cattles thymuses. Also what does produced by means of a technical process even means. Extraction from organs IS a technical process made of many reagents and steps. A synthetic production of a chemical in a lab via enzymes is a mostly biological process in my book, please clarify EU. 2) > assuming that the compund was previously not known to be usable for a particular use case Now that destroy most applications and its ridiculous. What happen about a substance is that at first their is base public access research. This base research find most uses, here that thymalin increase lymphocite T production. The goal of the base research is to enable future clinical trials years later. However since this base research has found the use, it's no longer patentable and therefore ironically prevent clinical trials. Now if applying an immunostimulant for X new immunosuppressive diseases is a separate patent despite deriving from the same basic public research property is valid.. is an open and ad-hoc question?

However to be perfectly honest, while my general statement about Peptides is true, there exists (unrelated to HIV) patents about thymalin I don't know how that is possible.

Re:Moderna’s HIV Vaccine Prepped for Trials in Africa by dekhn on Friday May 20, 2022 @10:05AM (#31447554)
There's a lot of good points in here, folks, based on experience.

In particular, this is one of the most important observations in science/medicine today:

" mediocrity and bad incentives have much more explanative power than malice, and yes some mainstream researchers have some erudition or intelligence but there are some systemic attractors that prevents them"

it wasn't until I left academia and got "tenure" at a large tech company that I was finally able to pursue the research I wanted to (for funding reasons) and when I finally did, it proved to a wide range of people that what I had been proposing was legitimate.

Re:Moderna’s HIV Vaccine Prepped for Trials in Africa by Mvandenbergh on Friday May 20, 2022 @06:51AM (#31445650)
I will take you at your own word. Where could someone read your meta-research if one wanted to? Even if that is on a non peer-reviewed Arxiv type site?
Re:Moderna’s HIV Vaccine Prepped for Trials in Africa by orangepurple on Friday May 20, 2022 @04:59AM (#31444932)
There are forums that enable "collaborative super-intelligence" but those are limited to illicit drug manufacturing
Re:Moderna’s HIV Vaccine Prepped for Trials in Africa by SemanticStrengh on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:02AM (#31444938)
What are you talking about? Research chemicals communities? Nootropics frontline forums?
Re:Moderna’s HIV Vaccine Prepped for Trials in Africa by monkey_monkey on Friday May 20, 2022 @08:08AM (#31446223)
Given how important your meta-research is, it's actually negligent of you to be wasting time arguing on this site.

Please link us to your website and to your research so we can help you in your mission to save millions of lives.

Re:Moderna’s HIV Vaccine Prepped for Trials in Africa by mthrowjlls on Friday May 20, 2022 @05:06AM (#31444969)
Hey made this just to answer I'm ignorant in the field and eager to learn, and yet I dismissed your comment as well This was not because 'humanity that simply don't care above the surface layer of attention nor care deeply about the human condition' but because you come across as a weird prick Be nicer maybe?