> Class solidarity and positional maintenance are the real objectives
Who's organizing all the world's corporate leaders? Who's preventing from non-infiltrated people from starting businesses? This is extremely conspiratorial
> Companies will do bad things to make a profit, and on rare occasions they even do good things to make a profit
Really? Rare occasions? Do you deal with any private businesses in your every day? 99% of my interactions with private businesses is positive. How can this be taken as a serious statement?
> Big companies don't go out of business because they're out-competed. They do so because their management loses the faith of the upper class and can no longer access investment, clients, resources, or political advantages.
Who's doing this coordination? Blockbuster drops the ball on streaming and Netflix came out with a better product and consumer tastes shifted away from in-store movie rentals to digital. I'm sure there's some conspiracy theory that Blockbuster execs offended "the upper class" so it was decided they need to go away.
I'm trying to read your comments in good-faith but I find it increasingly difficult to do so due to the conspiratorial nature of your argument.
Take a software startup I worked for later - they care about profits and they care about employee morale. They are out to make money and they need the best and the brightest. It affects their bottom line. A good dev can bring in millions in revenue. They give promotions, they retain. They tell their dumbass son/daughter who got hired to shut his/her mouth, be respectful, and not boss anyone around even if they do hire him/her.
I also see this in emerging economies - when the USSR collapsed, people really hired talent, because the markets were competitive. (Even though former USSR is famous for nepotism)
A lot of established companies in the US are truly not competitive and have the market cornered, hence some validity in the parent comment.
But, I personally know a number of guys who became directors in their 20s based on raw talent in Russian tech / e-commerce / straight up commerce companies. Despite what you said, there was a number of business opportunities there for younger people. There was also a lot of opportunities providing basic services - cellular, emergency vehicle support (coming out to change battery/tire), etc, etc. The market is too mature in the US for these "easy" businesses for young people.
Of course, we have the best funding for startups, but that's a bit of a higher bar for the average person.
Ok, we can all stop there and go home. This person knows more than every economist and game-theorist on the planet.
>They're all kinda the same, though, and the system is designed that way.
I take it you haven't had many jobs I've worked at 5 different corporations and this is just verifiably wrong. 'The system' you're referencing is voluntary exchange, and it's not designed, it emerges from the concept of private property.
The worker wants a pay rise, the manager wants a promotion, the CEO wants a better gig at the next company. None of that is a goal of making more money for the company.
The challenge of corporate governance is designing it so that the incentives for the individuals within it align with the goals of the corporation itself. Every "How to do startups" book written has some portion of it dedicated to "How to get your employees' wants to align with the company's." This is the primary difference between companies that thrive over long periods and those that die out quickly.
There are academic textbooks written on the subject. Its study is as old as the corporate structure itself.
This is quite literally the definition of Adam Smith's Invisible Hand.
"By preferring the support of domestic to that of foreign industry, he intends only his own security; and by directing that industry in such a manner as its produce may be of the greatest value, he intends only his own gain, and he is in this, as in many other cases, led by an invisible hand to promote an end which was no part of his intention. Nor is it always the worse for the society that it was not part of it. By pursuing his own interest he frequently promotes that of the society more effectually than when he really intends to promote it."
This is well known in economics, perverse incentives is one example used to describe this kind of discrepancy. Help desk people hanging up on what is expected to be very long calls when average call length is considered a critical metric.
My point was economists spend a lot of time investigating the mismatch because no company gets this completely correct.
The corporations I've worked for rewarded schmoozing with the manager much more than competence.
Maybe those other people disagreeing with you worked for different corporations?
I have no idea but I've worked for several corporations and they were all a mess in this way.
My current position as a software engineer with almost a decade of experience is a subordinate to a project manager who has one year of experience in tech and the project is millions of dollars and years behind schedule.
This being a tax payer funded project to create a system for a few hundred people...
The person in charge is friends with the manager and the manager is friends with the COO and on up the chain.
Previous position was for DXC technologies who fired my entire team except me and another and then hired offshore workers. They were also sued by their customers for providing poor quality software.
The business practices I've seen boggle my mind.